Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: As social beings, humans rely heavily on the ability to reason about others’ thoughts, known as Theory of Mind (ToM). Traditionally, ToM was thought to emerge around age four, but recent research using non-verbal tasks suggests that even infants may predict others’ actions based on their mental states. A recent theory proposes that infants pass non-verbal tasks by being socially biased to attend to what others deem relevant, leading to better encoding and memory of shared experiences. This thesis explores how infants pass non-verbal ToM tasks, focusing on social biases, precursors, and supporting neural networks. The research investigates two main questions: (A) What social cognitive processes and neural developments drive non-verbal ToM success? (Studies 1 and 3) (B) What precursors might help infants pass non-verbal tasks through mechanisms other than mature ToM reasoning? (Studies 2 and 3) The first study examined preschoolers' structural brain networks involved in non-verbal and verbal ToM tasks. Results revealed two distinct networks: a ventral network for non-verbal ToM tasks and a dorsal network for verbal ToM reasoning, overlapping with the Default network. The non-verbal tasks were linked to connections within the Salience network, which filters salient environmental stimuli, among which social cues are particularly salient. This suggests that young children use these cues, such as others’ attention, to predict other’s actions and succeed in non- verbal ToM tasks. The second study focused on joint attention, a behavioral precursor to ToM. Joint attention involves coordinating one’s attention on objects with others and thus may bias infants toward social cues. Resting-state fMRI data of infants showed that connectivity patterns predictive of joint attention also predicted verbal ToM abilities in preschoolers. These findings emphasized the role of the Salience and Default networks in helping infants transition from perceptual processing in the Salience network to more abstract social reasoning in the Default network. The third study tested whether joint attention enhances infants' memory of object locations, a key element in non-verbal ToM tasks. Using an adapted A-not-B task, where infants repeatedly search for an object in one location before it is moved to another, we found that joint attention did not improve infants' memory of the object's new location. This suggests that social cues' influence on memory may be fragile, and infants may use other strategies in non-verbal ToM tasks. Overall, the findings suggest that young children use strategies other than mature ToM reasoning to understand others, questioning theories of mature ToM before 4 years. Non-verbal ToM tasks in infancy likely rely on simpler mechanisms, such as socially influenced attention.
Author: Schüler, Clara
Institution: Leipzig University
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7083225339
