Work

A Kantian Solution to the Ethical-Environmental Problem

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Kant’s philosophy has often been criticized for its emphasis on the centrality of human beings and has been considered limited in its application to ethical issues related to nonrational nature. Against this perspective, this thesis aims to reassess Kant’s relevance to contemporary environmental philosophy, exploring how his thought can provide a solid foundation for tackling today’s ethical and environmental challenges. Drawing on a detailed analysis of Kant’s philosophical corpus, this study proposes an active interpretation that incorporates cooperative, aesthetic, holistic, teleological, progressive, dynamic, systematic and critical aspects, aiming to promote environmental duty. The first part of the thesis focuses on animal ethics, beginning with an examination of Peter Singer’s argument for moral equality. It then explores critiques of Kant’s notion of indirect duties, particularly those put forth by Arthur Schopenhauer, Tom Regan and Christina Hoff. Building on this critical framework, the discussion turns to responses from Allen Wood and Christine Korsgaard, as well as the perspectives of Patrick Kain and Matthew Altman. A key analytical focus is the distinction between possessing “universal dignity” and achieving “deep dignity”. The second part of the thesis explores the idea of an ethics applied to nature, specifically through an analysis of Aldo Leopold’s Land Ethic and Arne Næss’s Deep Ecology. The argument is made that Kant’s concept of aesthetic disinterest offers valuable insights for eco-aesthetics. In the realm of ecosophy, practical rationality carries the duty of fostering a moral relationship with nature. From a contemporary standpoint, Kantian thought offers conceptual tools to support an environmental ethics capable of addressing the pressing challenges of today’s ecological crisis. The categorical imperative should guide sustainable practices, aligning with a progressive vision of humanity and balancing individual and collective responsibility. In this context, Kantian pedagogy plays a key role in shaping ethical and environmental values. Finally, the third part of the thesis explores, through a Kantian lens, debates on moral vegetarianism, the use of animals in science and education, monoculture farming and habitat destruction.
Language: Portuguese
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7084219502
Cites: 312
Cited by:
Related to: 10