Evaluating the Effects of Benzalkonium Chloride (bac) on Early-life Stage and Juvenile Rainbow Trout (oncorhynchus Mykiss)
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Benzalkonium chloride (BAC), a widely used quaternary ammonium compound (QAC) with antimicrobial properties, has seen increased usage in recent years. Due to its frequent use and incomplete removal by conventional wastewater treatment processes, BAC is considered a pseudo-persistent contaminant and has been detected in aquatic environments worldwide. This persistence has raised concerns about its potential ecological impacts, particularly on non-target aquatic organisms. Previous studies have reported both lethal and sub-lethal effects of BAC in fish, important bioindicators of aquatic ecosystem health, including delayed embryonic development, developmental abnormalities, reproductive impairments, and molecular-level disruptions. However, much of this research has focused on model species (e.g., zebrafish). Among fish species, rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) is of particular concern due to its ecological importance, commercial value, and widespread use as a standardized model organism in aquatic toxicology. Despite its relevance, data on BAC toxicity in rainbow trout remain limited, particularly for early-life stage (ELS) and juvenile fish. Key knowledge gaps include the effects of sub-chronic exposure on survival and development in ELS fish, transcriptomic responses to short-term BAC exposure, and potential disruptions to the gut microbiome. These endpoints are crucial for understanding how antimicrobial contaminants, such as BAC, may impact vulnerable life stages that are essential for population sustainability. In addition, tissue-specific molecular responses in juvenile rainbow trout following acute BAC exposure have not been previously explored. Therefore, this thesis aimed to investigate both apical and sub-lethal biological responses to BAC exposure in rainbow trout across sensitive life stages. Specifically, we evaluated survival, developmental outcomes, tissue-specific transcriptomic responses (including from non-lethal samples), and gut microbiome composition following environmentally relevant and elevated BAC exposures in both ELS and juvenile rainbow trout. Chapter 2 examined newly-hatched ELS trout exposed sub-chronically for 28 days post-hatch (dph) to waterborne BAC concentrations ranging from 0.38 – 320 µg/L. At 4-dph, six alevins per tank were randomly sub-sampled for transcriptomic profiling using the EcoToxChip, a targeted qPCR-based gene expression platform developed to screen for mechanistic toxicity signals across multiple biological pathways. At the conclusion of the exposure, gastrointestinal tracts from three fish per tank were pooled for next-generation 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing to assess gut microbiome responses. No significant effects on survival or development were observed across the concentrations tested. Transcriptomic analysis revealed only eight differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and gut microbiome composition showed minimal changes, with modest shifts in select bacterial families at the highest (320 µg/L) exposure level. Chapter 3 focused on juvenile trout exposed acutely over 96 hours to 2 – 1,250 µg/L BAC, encompassing a previously reported LC50 value. Following exposure, blood samples and fin clips were collected non-lethally, followed by humane euthanasia and collection of gill, liver, gastrointestinal tract, and brain tissues. Transcriptomic responses were assessed in the liver, gill, and the non-lethally sampled blood. The inclusion of non-lethal samples aimed to evaluate their potential utility for biomonitoring, such as in field studies or repeated sampling designs. These tissues were analyzed for transcriptomic responses using the EcoToxChip. There was no mortality over the 96-h exposure. Transcriptomic analysis revealed limited but tissue-specific responses, with the liver showing the highest number of DEGs, followed by blood and gill. A comparison between non-lethal (blood) and lethal (liver) sampling revealed only one shared DEG, suggesting limited overlap in molecular responses between these tissues under the exposure conditions tested. Given the low number of DEGs overall, these results may reflect either true biological resilience or the potential for weak or stochastic gene expression responses at sub-lethal exposure levels when using a focused gene panel. Overall, this thesis fills critical knowledge gaps related to BAC toxicity during the early developmental life stages of rainbow trout. Both ELS and juvenile fish exhibited resilience to direct BAC exposure across environmentally relevant and elevated concentrations, with no significant apical effects observed. Sub-lethal molecular effects were weak and highly tissue-specific, and gut microbiome shifts were minimal. While BAC adsorption at epithelial surfaces (e.g., gills) may occur, limited systemic uptake likely contributed to the absence of robust toxicological responses. This research presents the first tissue-level transcriptomic assessment of BAC in rainbow trout, highlighting the importance of integrating multiple biological endpoints when evaluating sub-lethal toxicity. Given the low hazard potential for BAC observed with waterborne exposure, future research may prioritize exploring alternative exposure routes (e.g., sediment or dietary) and focus on specific modes of toxicity, such as neurotoxicity, behavioural alterations, immunotoxicity, and reproductive impairment, to better characterize potential long-term ecological risks.
Author: Kohlman, Evan Arron Spencer
Institution: University of Saskatchewan
Language: English
Subfield: Health, Toxicology and Mutagenesis
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: benzalkonium chloride, quaternary ammonium compounds, rainbow trout, fish early life stages, juvenile fish, subchronic exposure, sublethal toxicity, transcriptomic response, gut microbiota, antimicrobial contaminants, developmental abnormalities, tissue-specific gene expression, 16S rRNA gene sequencing, 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing, 18S rRNA sequencing, 16S rRNA metagenomics
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7084259612
