Work

Statistical Literacy: A Prerequisite for Evidence-Based Medicine

Year: 2007
Type: editorial
Abstract: Currently in the United States a prostate cancer drug is being touted in a novel way: The primary benefit of the drug is claimed to be not that it reduces the risk of the disease, but rather that it reduces the risk of being treated for the disease.''Men are getting screened, discovering that they have cancers that may or may not be dangerous, and opting for treatments that can leave them impotent or incontinent . . .Preventing the cancer can prevent treatments that can be debilitating, even if the cancers were never lethal to start with'' (Kolata, 2008, p. A1).Such is the state of doctor-patient communication: Most doctors and virtually all patients are unschooled in how meaningfully to compare the risks of foregoing versus undergoing treatment, and the patient's frantic desire to ''do something, now'' often trumps the doctor's ancient commitment to ''first, do no harm.''The problem that Gigerenzer, Gaissmaier, Kurz-Milcke, Schwartz, and Woloshin address in this exemplar of interdisciplinary and international collaboration could hardly be more pressing.Marshalling one study after another, they demonstrate that, across widely varying samples of health professionals, patients, and policymakers, in all countries studied, statistical illiteracy reigns supreme-often with catastrophic consequences for individual and public health.The media function as enablers of this problem.For example, while the author of the newspaper article quoted in the previous paragraph showed unusual journalistic insight by noting the irony of inoculating people against treatment rather than against disease, she still expressed the benefit of the drug in terms of relative risk reduction (''dropping the incidence [of prostate cancer] by 30 percent''; Kolata, 2008, p. A1) rather than in the muchless-dramatic terms of absolute risk reduction recommended in these pages.Clearer risk communication would go far in helping patients make informed and intelligent trade-offs between the costs and the benefits of various medical interventions, including the nonintervention of ''let's wait and see.''Innumeracy, as this monograph makes abundantly clear, is an enormous societal problem.Even if statistical literacy could be achieved by following the sensible and feasible recommendations of Gigerenzer and his colleagues, however, the issue of what people take to be credible ''evidence'' in evidence-based medicine and public
Source: Gothic.net
Author: John Monahan
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2140754794
Cites: 9
Cited by: 10
Related to: 9