Work

Civil Passions: Moral Sentiment and Democratic Deliberation

Year: 2011
Type: book-review
Abstract: W hat is the appropriate role of passions in democracy?Sharon Krause's Civil Passions adds to the debate on this highly contested question in democratic theory.Faculty and other professionals whose work includes deliberative forums or related forms of engagement will find this book to be an important contribution addressing the critical question of how to reconcile impartiality with passions.While many would contend that deliberation within a liberal democracy must leave out passions so rational judgments can be made, Krause contends that passions can and should contribute positively to the process.She argues that passions and moral sentiment are already involved in practical reasoning and should be acknowledged as such.Krause situates her argument between those who hold a neo-Kantian position stating that reason alone motivates individuals to act or make decisions, and those who perceive the role of passion and emotion in motivation and decision-making.She states that "our theories of moral judgment and democratic deliberation have been caught on the horns of a dilemma: they have either been too rationalistic to motivate action and decision, or they have been too indiscriminately rooted in the passions to carry normative weight" (6).Krause argues for a notion of impartiality that takes seriously the role of moral sentiments in democratic practice.This "middle way" of moral sentiments shaping impartiality ends up being a fine line to walk that offers questionable likelihood of success.Nevertheless, engaged scholars who work in and with communities in decision-making capacities should wrestle with this question.The struggle for determining what should shape democratic practice in communities that seek equal justice and voice for citizens is at the heart of what Krause engages.The starting point for her argument is based on Hume because of the "fruitful way in which his theory of judgment combines impartiality with affective engagement" (14).From this starting point, however, Krause moves well beyond the limitations of the eighteenth century to questions Hume could not answer.Chapter 1 focuses on Rawls and Habermas as exemplars of the rationalist position, specifically on the topic of justice.The most important
Institution: Cornell University
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W1690965847
Cites: 1
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9