Work

Men and meanings of murder: discourses and power in narratives of male homicide in South Africa

Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The extant South African literature base on male homicide is relatively small and reveals a \npaucity of qualitative studies. This study aimed to elicit discourses embedded within the \nnarratives of men involved in homicidal encounters, and to analyse them from a social \nconstructionist perspective. Semi-structured, individual interviews were conducted with 30 \nmale prisoners who were convicted of murder. An analysis of narrative forms, followed by a \ncritical discourse analysis of the narrative contents, was conducted and aimed to assess the \nsocial and ideological significance, functions and effects of these discourses. Participants' \ntalk included masculine performances that allowed for positive self-presentation and ways of \nconstructing meaning of their actions for themselves, the interviewer and an `invisible \naudience'. Narrative forms of stability/continuity, decline, and transformation/growth that \nrelied on normalising, reifying, tipping point, propitiatory and rehabilitatory lexical registers \nwere deployed as a means to position participants as reasonable, normal, rehabilitated, and as \n`successful' men. Within the narrative contents, participants constructed homicide through \nexculpatory and justificatory discourses to rationalise and minimise their agency, and drew \non essentialist, moral and deterministic notions of male violence. Discourses of spectacular \nand instrumental violence were also evident. References to male honour, status and power; a \ndefence against emasculation; the assertion of control over commodified female partners; the \nmaintenance of referent familist and ageist discourses; and the normalisation of male \nviolence as a utilitarian tool to access resources in unequal social contexts, underpinned these \ndiscourses. The homicidal acts thus represented adapted performances of hegemonic \nmasculinity in a noxious context where this dominant form of masculinity is often \nunattainable. While participants' talk reproduced hegemonic constructions of masculinity \nwithin broader social contexts, it also contested hegemonic orders of moral discourses that \ngovern the legitimacy or illegitimacy of violence. The findings reveal how contexts of \ndiscoursal production have a contradictory response to violence - denouncing it, but also \nsimultaneously acting as a pernicious incubatory environment for male homicide. It \nconcludes that the prevention of male homicide must involve the de-linking of masculinities \nand violence at material, structural and institutional levels, but also within systems of \nsignification, if non-violent masculinities are to gain ascendancy.
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W70999806
Cites: 351
Cited by: 28
Related to: 10