Why spatial-numeric associations aren't evidence for a mental number line
Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: In the well-known SNARC effect, people are shown to be faster at responding to relatively large numbers with their right hands, and to relatively small numbers with their left hands, on magnitude-irrelevant tasks. It is typically assumed that both the SNARC effect and the Simon effect—in which right-hand responses are facilitated when stimuli appear on the right-hand side—are explained by spatial mappings of stimulus to response; where the former is the result of representing numbers spatially (i.e. along a mental number line) and mapping right-hand responses to large numbers and left-hand responses to small numbers, and the latter is the result of responding to stimuli on the right side of visual space with the right hand and vice-versa. However, the principle of polarity correspondence can also account for these findings; this theory asserts that in binary representations of dimensions, one pole is dominant and tasks are facilitated when dominant stimulus values are mapped to dominant response values. In previous studies, dominance and spatial mapping have been confounded. The current paper uses non-spatial responses (spoken “yes ” and “no ” responses) to consider whether polarity correspondence can account for the SNARC effect.
Authors: David Landy, Erin L. Jones, John E. Hummel
Institution: University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Award: G1523888516
OpenAlex ID: W13424712
