Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Citizens’ experience of inclusion takes shape in the moments and situations where they interact with public authorities, such as urban planners. At the same time, a lack of democratic culture remains visible in urban planning. Although Finland introduced internationally ambitious participatory planning legislation as early as the 1990s, citizens’ actual opportunities to influence the planning of their living environments remain limited. Urban planning culture and institutional practices have been found to constrain these opportunities, often reducing participation to a formal exercise. This dissertation examines the disconnection between participatory perspectives and urban planning outcomes through the concept of polyphony. The aim is to deepen understanding of the meanings of polyphony in urban planning and to develop practices that can support more polyphonic planning. The research is situated within current legislative and digital reforms in Finnish urban planning, as well as the broader diversification of society, where increasingly plural communities and new forms of participation challenge traditional planning models. The empirical data consist of three case studies conducted in municipalities in the Helsinki metropolitan area: Nikkilä in Sipoo, Kontula in Helsinki, and Viiskorpi in Espoo. The cases address the role of participatory knowledge in valuing cultural environments, self-organized participation among entrepreneurs with immigrant backgrounds, and the construction of dialogical processes through hybrid participatory methods. Two of the cases employed an action research approach, in which the aim was not only to understand the phenomenon but also to influence it and develop practices in collaboration with participants. Methodologically, the research applies a multidisciplinary and multi-method approach, combining case studies, action research, and abductive reasoning. The research process is dialogical and iterative. The theoretical framework is grounded in planning theory, particularly in the tradition of communicative planning, which is further developed through the concept of polyphony, drawn from the literary theory of Mikhail Bakhtin. The dissertation presents a framework for polyphonic urban planning, which is used to explore the dialogical nature of participatory planning, its representations, and the agencies involved. The study argues that adopting and integrating polyphony into urban planning practices can strengthen a democratic planning culture. Polyphony is not only an abstract ideal or normative goal but also a practical tool for understanding and transforming the structures and agencies of urban planning.
Source: Aaltodoc (Aalto University)
Author: Harsia-Mikkola, Eveliina
Institution: Aalto University
Language: English
Subfield: Urban Studies
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7111790524
