Understanding the Relationship Between Social Determinants of Health and Anxiety and Depression
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: The World Health Organization describes social determinants of health (including mental health) as “the conditions in which people are born, grow, live, work and age, and people’s access to power, money and resources”. Understanding how social determinants impact anxiety and depression may generate recommendations in how to reduce the impact of social determinants on mental health. The first chapter explores the relationship between subjective social status (SSS) and mental health disorders, specifically anxiety and depression. Subjective social status refers to how an individual perceives their social standing (e.g., in relation to their employment and income) relative to others. A search of existing literature for published studies in this area was conducted. Studies were required to include participants who were 18 years or older, who had completed a specific measure of subjective socials status called the Macarthur ladder and a measure relating to anxiety and/or depression. In total, 65 studies were identified. Of these, 41 could be analysed quantitatively using meta-analysis. The findings suggested SSS is weakly associated with mental health, whereby lower SSS is associated with increased depressive and anxiety symptoms (i.e., small effect size). This did not appear to differ according to whether different versions of the Macarthur Ladder were used for neither anxiety nor depression. For depression, it also appeared this did not differ according to where the study was conducted or how old participants were. However, when considering the results of all 65 studies (descriptively, not quantitatively), there was some evidence to suggest the relationship between SSS and mental health may differ when looking at subgroups of individuals, according to how identity characteristics interact (e.g., race/age). Additionally, certain social factors and thinking styles appear to play an important role in influencing the relationship between SSS and mental health. However, further research in these areas is needed to quantitively summarise whether/how different variables impact the relationship between SSS and mental health. The second chapter aimed to characterise the relationship between various social determinants of health with anxiety and depression, in a sample of individuals who closely represent the English population. A network model approach was used, which is a graphical and statistical way of exploring which factors are connected and how strongly. Two models were created, one looking at the relationship between social determinants and anxiety and another with depression. Overall, each model explained a noticeable amount of variance in anxiety and depressive symptoms. The determinants having the greatest direct impact on both anxiety and depression related to how lonely someone is, how many positive childhood experiences they have experienced, whether they are in receipt of benefits, and how old they are. Other determinants relating to socioeconomic status appeared to have an indirect effect on anxiety and depression. Overall, the study highlights that social determinants contribute to population-level mental health, and interventions which address relational and socioeconomic factors will likely reduce anxiety and depressive symptoms in adults in England.
Author: Sinclair Emerson, Rosa
Institution: University of Sheffield
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7111983211
