Work

Legal Pragmatism : A Comparison with the Nordic Legal Method

Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: The article explores the evolution of Nordic legal pragmatism through a comparison withother European legal traditions, particularly that of Italy. The authors analyze the definingcharacteristics and historical development of a pragmatic approach in Nordic law, particularly inSweden, one that prioritizes problem-solving over theoretical abstraction. Tracing Nordic legalpragmatism back to medieval statutes, which were casuistic and practical rather thanconceptually systematic, and the relatively minimal influence of Roman law, the authorshighlight the unique trajectory of Nordic law in contrast to the rest of Europe. Over time, thisapproach fostered an emphasis on social utility and democratic processes, notably expressedin Scandinavian legal realism, which rejected metaphysical legal concepts. The article furtherexamines how pragmatism continues to permeate Swedish law today, evident in legaleducation, legal scholarship and judicial practices, where court judgments emphasize concise,context-sensitive reasoning over conceptual and argumentative diversity. Comparativeanalyses underscore that this pragmatic approach is a hallmark of the Nordic legal tradition,setting it apart from the more theory-driven continental European legal systems.
Authors: Kelemen, Katalin, Valguarnera, Filippo
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7112074950
FWCI: 1.357
Cites: 5
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10