Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Voice-hearing is popularly interpreted as solely a phenomenological experience – the perception of a voice without external stimuli. However, voices are often understood by the voice-hearer as communicative actions by discrete agents with particular identities. That is, voices are not necessarily unresponsive commenters but may, for example, respond to questions or otherwise react to how they are spoken to. That any instance of language should seem to come from a specific agentive speaker is in line with sociocultural linguistic understandings of language as necessarily deeply social. “Language without a speaker” makes little sense; every act of language is infused with social meaning. Nevertheless, most medicalized ideologies within European psychiatric tradition dictate that voices should be understood as meaningless pathology rather than communicative in any real way. Some newer therapeutic modalities, however, emphasize “engagement” with voices as a possible alternative to psychiatric medication, thereby rendering voices as potential conversational partners. This leads to the central question of this dissertation: Within these different interpretive frameworks, how do voice-hearers position – or avoid positioning – voices as social agents? To explore the nature of voices as social agents, this dissertation draws from ethnographic interviews with 15 self-identified voice-hearers located across the United States and United Kingdom, alongside clinical and community discourses about voice-hearing. Ultimately, this dissertation demonstrates that sociocultural linguistic understandings of agency need to be able to account for such “atypical speakers”.
Author: Parish, Ayden Marzelle
Institution: University of California, Berkeley
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: voice hearing, social agency, psychosis
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7112354932
