Should I Stay or Should I Go? : First-Line Managers' Experiences and Factors Influencing Retention and Turnover in Healthcare
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Aim: The overall aim of this thesis was to generate knowledge and understanding of first-line managers' experiences of the factors influencing their retention and turnover, including their self-reported work-related stress, job satisfaction, span of control, leadership and management performance, and how these factors interact and change over time. Methods: Four studies were conducted in a Swedish regional healthcare organization. Studies I and III used qualitative descriptive designs with semi-structured interviews to explore reasons for staying or leaving. Study II was a repeated cross-sectional survey assessing associations among span of control, leadership and management performance, work-related stress, and job satisfaction, including the stability of these associations. Study IV was a 40-month prospective cohort using Cox regression to examine whether these factors were associated with time to leave. Results: Managers who stayed emphasized trust, autonomy, meaningful relationships, and support from colleagues and superiors, together with a sense of purpose in influencing staff and patient care. Those who left often described tipping points linked to high demands, limited influence, or insufficient support. In Study II, job satisfaction remained stable over time and was positively associated with control, manager and peer support, and role clarity; high demands and poor relationships showed strong negative associations. In Study IV, 28 managers left in 40 months. Being categorized at a moderate level in control and manager support was associated with a higher risk of leaving, whereas workplace relationships were not significant. Conclusion: Retention and turnover among first-line managers are shaped by organizational, group, and individual experiences. Role clarity, supportive relations, sufficient resources, and meaningfulness are central to sustaining engagement and reducing stress, which influence first-line managers’ willingness to remain in their role.
Source: DiVA (University of Gävle)
Author: Svanström, Jonas
Institution: University of Gävle
Language: English
Subfield: Research and Theory
Field: Nursing
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7112611963
