Transformative AI agency:How students negotiate and collaborate on the role of generative artificial intelligence in higher education
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: There is growing interest in integrating generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in higher education, but less attention has been paid to how students actively negotiate AI’s role in learning. This exploratory case study examines how students engage with ChatGPT not only as a tool for knowledge acquisition but as a mediating artifact that shapes and is shaped by student interactions. Based on qualitative data, including group interactions, focus groups, written reflections, and ChatGPT logs, we explore how students critically respond to and reshape AI’s role when working with academic literature. Based on transformative agency and double stimulation, we argue that ChatGPT functions as a first stimulus that provokes tensions and leads students to create second stimuli, such as collaborative strategies, group norms, and critical dialogues. Our findings show that meaningful engagement with ChatGPT occurs when students actively collaborate and reflect on the output of ChatGPT, leading to the rephrasing of questions (prompts), and, in the process, the students construct or reconstruct new knowledge. Thus, we argue that GenAI should be understood as a negotiable and mediating artifact and that fostering transformative agency is key to supporting critical and creative uses of GenAI in education.
Authors: Camilla Finsterbach Kaup, Møller, Anders Kalsgaard
Institution: XLAB (Slovenia)
Language: Danish
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7112661153
