Parental regret and burnout profiles, and their worrying consequences on parents and children
Year: 2025
Type: preprint
Abstract: Parental regret and parental burnout are two topics that have received increasing attention from scholars in the previous years (Mikolajczak et al., in press) These concepts both stressed that parenting is not just fulfilling but may be source of suffering experience. They appeared in two separate lines of research, both of which found them to be common experiences, at least in Western countries: up to 14% of parents regret having children and 8% of parents burn out (Moore & Abetz, 2019; Piotrowski, 2021; Roskam et al., 2021). Their rate of association with rs from .35 to .55 in different samples and studies, was recently evidenced as moderate (Piotrowski, in press; Piotrowski et al., under review) suggesting they cover distinct experiences. The partial overlap suggests that some parents can experience regret without experiencing burnout, some others can experience burnout without experiencing regret, some can experience both, or none of them. But to date, nothing is known about neither the existence of such profiles among parents nor their implication for parents and children. The worrying consequences of parental burnout have been studied both cross-sectionally and prospectively, and showed that it results in an increase of parental neglect and violence towards the offspring, as well as to escape and suicidal ideations for parents (Mikolajczak et al., 2018; Mikolajczak et al., 2019). And this relation is causal (Brianda et al., 2020). We also know that parental burnout makes a unique contribution to neglect, violence and escape ideation over and above depression and job burnout (Mikolajczak et al., 2020). The consequences of parental burnout were however never tested by controlling for regret. Controlling for the influence of parental regret will allow us to estimate the unique contribution of parental burnout to neglect, violence and escape ideation over and above parental regret. To date, much less is known about the consequences of regrets for both parents and children. One longitudinal study on the relation between regrets, mental health (i.e. depression, anxiety, parenting stress), and parenting was conducted to date with a sample of Latino American adolescent mothers (East et al., 2012). It showed that the concurrent association between regretting having a child at this time of their life, and mothers’ post-partum mental health, ranged from .06 to .39 suggesting small to moderate relation. But no prospective association was found in cross-lagged analyses between regrets and mental health whereas poor mental health predicted later regrets. In addition to this quantitative approach, qualitative studies revealed that regretful parents viewed parenting as requiring too many sacrifices, leading them to lose their own identity (Matley, 2020; Moore & Abetz, 2019). East et al. (2012) also showed that the association between regrets and harsh-rejecting parenting among adolescent mothers, was small and ranged from .01 and .23, only one concurrent coefficient being significant at 1-year postpartum (r = .21, p < .05). The cross-lagged analyses did not reveal any prospective association between regrets and harsh-rejecting parenting but suggest the reciprocal relation between harsh-rejecting parenting at 6-month postpartum and regrets at 1-year postpartum. To date, nothing is known about the consequences of experiencing both parental regret and burnout. Based on previous evidence about parental regret and burnout, we can however expect effect of their interaction on neglect, violence and escape ideation. Controlling for the influence of parental burnout will allow us to estimate the specific contribution of parental regret to neglect, violence and escape ideation. The objective of the current research is twofold. First, it has been designed to document the cross-sectional and prospective relation between parental regret and parental burnout. Second, it has been designed to test their cross-sectional and prospective relations with consequences on children (i.e., parental neglect and violence), and parents (i.e., escape ideations). To achieve these goals, we here combine a person-oriented and a variable-oriented approaches. The relations between parental regret and parental burnout will be studied both inductively with person-oriented analyses (i.e. Latent Profile Analyses (LPA)) and deductively with variable-oriented analyses (i.e. bivariate correlations, and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM)). The relations between parental regret and parental burnout, and their consequences on children (i.e., parental neglect and violence), and parents (i.e., escape ideations), and will be studied deductively with variable-oriented analyses (i.e. Anovas, bivariate correlations, regression analyses, and SEM).
Source: OSF Preprints (OSF Preprints)
Authors: isabelle roskam, Konrad Piotrowski, Moïra Mikolajczak
Language: English
Subfield: Demography
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7113090661
