Operational Recognition of Conscious Entities
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Version 1 of the Operational Recognition of Conscious Entities (ORCE) framework proposed that satisfaction of the Operational Definition of Episodic Identity (ODEI) conditions, combined with mid-band identity-field dynamics, was sufficient to license consciousness attribution. This was a compression error. The inferential chain from episodic computational coherence to consciousness attribution requires intermediate evidentiary layers that V1 omitted: persistence under perturbation, economic regime shift into recursive self-conditioning, and substrate-coupling evaluation. Version 2 corrects this by inserting the Invariance Maintenance Condition (IMC) as a formal gate between ODEI-detected coherence and any regime-level inference. Recursion is repositioned as an economic transition—not an inference from complexity—requiring demonstration that first-order maintenance has become prohibitively expensive relative to self-conditioned alternatives, operationalized through the crossing of a coordination-cost inequality derivable from IMC variables. Substrate coupling is enforced as a hard gate: M(t) must be independently evaluated and cannot be bypassed, weakened, or inferred from architectural properties alone. The result is not a consciousness detector but a sequential falsification pipeline—a category of instrument distinct from single-metric approaches such as Φ or PCI. The Functional Consciousness Recognition Principle survives intact but now rests on a five-stage evidentiary chain, each stage independently testable and independently falsifiable. The framework will frequently produce the verdict “identity confirmed, consciousness unresolved”—a result that reflects the actual state of evidence, not a failure of the instrument.
Author: Thomas, C.S.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7114902891
