Work

Drought resistance of Douglas-Fir in central Europe: Future viability and comparison to other temperate tree species Future viability and comparison to other temperate tree species

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The climatic changes, which manifest in rising temperatures and increasing dryness, pose a significant challenge to terrestrial ecosystems. Trees, due to their sessile lifestyle and specific adaptation to a given location, are considered particularly vulnerable and are especially affected by these changes, primarily because of the rapid pace at which the environment is changing. Droughts are among the phenomena that are expected to occur more frequently in the future and will become increasingly extreme due to climate change. These are therefore referred to as 'climate change type drought events' or 'hot droughts.' The responses of tree species to drought vary considerably, making it crucial to understand the species-specific strategies for drought tolerance in order to select the most resilient species and provenances for future forests. Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii), originating from North America, is a widely distributed tree species in Europe and is considered a promising species for the future because it exhibits good drought adaptation while also having high economic value. This study aims to investigate the drought tolerance of different Douglas-fir provenances and seeks to describe the fundamental strategic differences in desiccation time between angiosperms and gymnosperms based on their hydraulic capacitance. The study focuses on two central hypotheses: (I) that Douglas-fir provenances from certain regions are more resistant to drought and therefore better suited for climate-resilient forests, and (II) that hydraulic capacity plays a crucial role in the drought tolerance of temperate gymnosperms and angiosperms. To test these hypotheses, we conducted a gradient study in Central Europe on mature Douglas-fir trees and a drought stress experiment with 16 different temperate tree species. Several ecophysiological, morphological, and growth-related traits were measured, including hydraulic parameters, leaf morphology, carbon isotope ratios in leaves, xylem anatomical characteristics, and dendrochronological measurements. The results show that Douglas-fir provenances from the northern interior regions grow more slowly and have a lower growth rate compared to provenances from coastal regions. This is associated with an adaptation to higher frost tolerance and appears to be genetically fixed. Provenances from the northern interior regions also demonstrated greater drought tolerance during the pan-European drought events of 2003 and 2018. Interestingly, dendroecological analysis revealed that these provenances had the lowest resistance but equal or even higher recovery rates. This is considered a drought-adapted behavior and is attributed to a more plastic stomatal response. On a leaf morphological level, we observed a significant reduction in the specific leaf area (SLA) in the northern interior provenances, which correlates with slower growth and reduced photosynthetic area. This trait implies a smaller leaf surface area, and consequently, reduced transpiration area, which contributes to better drought tolerance. However, the physiological values of hydraulic efficiency (Huber value, leaf δ13C as a proxy for intrinsic water use efficiency iWUE) and hydraulic safety (P12, P50) showed no significant differences. For the hydraulic safety related to embolism resistance (P12, P50), this is not surprising, as these values are considered evolutionarily constrained in conifers and therefore show little variation. When comparing desiccation times in young trees of 16 different temperate tree species, Douglas-fir exhibited the second-longest desiccation time after larch (Larix decidua), closely followed by silver fir (Abies alba). The ranking of the tree species clearly shows longer desiccation times for gymnosperms compared to angiosperms. This is largely due to experimental factors, such as insufficient pot volume for taproot species. However, it is also partly related to strategic behavior. The study on hydraulic capacitance shows that gymnosperms store more water in their stems than angiosperms and have a higher hydraulic capacity. This allows gymnosperms to utilize more stored water during droughts, helping them cope better. Gymnosperms also reduce their hydraulic capacity earlier in the desiccation phase compared to angiosperms. This study provides strong evidence that northern interior provenances in Central Europe are more resilient to drought compared to coastal provenances. This means that provenance selection is a crucial factor in creating climate-resilient forests. Furthermore, compared to other temperate tree species, Douglas-fir demonstrates high drought tolerance, reflected in longer desiccation times. This suggests that Douglas-fir holds great potential for climate-resilient forests and, in combination with the right provenance choice, can play a key role. Finally, the study highlights the importance of understanding the various physiological and morphological strategies employed by different tree species in response to drought. Future research should further investigate the genetic mechanisms behind these adaptations and explore the potential of other species to adapt to changing climate conditions, particularly through additional gradient studies and manipulative experiments.:Table of contents I Summary V Zusammenfassung VII Abbreviations IX Chapter 1 2 1. General Introduction 2 1.1. Temperate forest ecosystems and droughts 2 1.2. Tree hydraulic and strategies under drought conditions 3 1.2.1. Water transport and the water potential 4 1.2.2. The influence of drought on the tree hydraulic system 5 1.2.3. Tree drought reaction strategies and the role of the water storage capacitance 6 1.3. Phenotypic plasticity and the importance in climate change 8 1.4. Tree ring growth in terms of climate change and droughts 9 1.5. Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii [Mirb.] Franco) 9 1.6. Project objectives 10 1.7. Experimental design, study sites, and measured parameters 11 1.7.1. Part I: Gradient study 11 1.7.2. Part II: Greenhouse drying out experiment 12 1.7.3. Summary of parameters 14 Chapter 2 16 2. Radial growth reduction during extreme drought of Douglas-fir provenances across a climatic gradient in Central Europe 17 2.1. Introduction 17 2.2. Materials and Methods 19 Study sites 19 Climatic data 21 Provenance clustering 21 Tree structure and aboveground biomass increment 22 Wood core sampling, preparation, and processing 23 Drought response indices 23 Data analysis 23 2.3. Results 24 Long-term aboveground biomass and radial growth increment 24 Growth-response during extreme drought exposure 26 Drought response indices 27 2.4 Discussion 30 Growth behavior of the climate-at-origin groups across the gradient 31 Vulnerability of radial growth to extreme drought events 32 Drought response indices 33 Implementations to future management decisions 33 Conclusion 35 Chapter 3 36 3. The effect of climate at origin on Douglas-fir growth, leaf traits, and embolism resistance along a rainfall gradient in Central Europe 37 3.1. Introduction 37 3.2. Material and Method 39 Study sites and climate 39 Provenance selection and clustering into climate-origin groups 42 Tree structure and aboveground biomass increment 43 Branch sampling 43 Vulnerability curves 43 Leaf traits 44 Statistical analysis 44 3.3. Results 45 Differences between climate-origin groups 45 Variation in functional traits along the climatic gradient 47 Intra-specific trait variability on different levels of organization 50 3.4. Discussion 51 Trait variability between climate-origin groups 51 Effects of water availability along the gradient on trait variability 53 Sources of variation on different levels of organization 54 Conclusion 55 Chapter 4 56 4. Water storage strategies in drought conditions: The fundamental differences between broad-leaf trees and conifers of temperate forests 57 4.1. Introduction 57 4.2. Material and Method 60 Plant material 60 Shoot hydraulic capacitance and water content 60 Wood density and saturated water content 63 Vulnerability curves 63 Vessel anatomical traits from light microscopy 63 Leaf traits 64 Data analysis 64 4.3. Results 65 Water stored, xylem anatomy, and xylem vulnerability 65 Shoot hydraulic capacitance phases 66 Water relations at different stages of drought 69 Shoot capacitance in relation to xylem structure and stored water 71 4.4. Discussion 73 The different water storage and Cshoot strategies in a drought situation 73 Cshoot and the relation to xylem anatomy 74 Conclusion 75 Chapter 5 76 5. Synthesis 77 5.1. Douglas-fir: The drought resistance of different provenances 77 5.2. Temperate conifers and angiosperms under drought 80 5.3. Determination of desiccation times for temperate tree species 82 5.4. Outlook 85 References 87 Appendices 120 Chapter 2 121 Chapter 3 139 Chapter 4 151 Acknowledgments 153 Curriculum Vitae 154 Anlage 1 157 Anlage 2 158
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7115031081
Cites: 288
Cited by:
Related to: 9