Work

Sustainability Reporting Quality and the EU’s Non-Financial Disclosure Mandate : A Content Analysis Covering 10 Years of Reports Published by Finnish Public Companies

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The topic of this thesis is sustainability reporting quality (SRQ) and how it is affected by mandatory sustainability reporting. Voluntary sustainability reporting has been criticised as symbolic and of low quality. Mandatory sustainability reporting has been suggested to improve the problem. The European Union implemented a directive in the mid-2010's called the Non-Financial Reporting Directive to regulate sustainability reporting by large public interest companies operating in the EU. The directive applied for the first time to reports concerning fiscal years starting in 2017. This thesis presents a study consisting of a quantitative content analysis and a multiple linear regression analysis. The aim of the study is to expand upon existing mandatory SRQ research by addressing the potential of a pre-existing positive trend in SRQ, as well as, contributing to the generalisation of results by analysing contents from a different EU country (Finland) in comparison to previous research. The content analysis relies on a 19-point SRQ index which is compiled specifically for this thesis based on previous research. Analysed reports are scored based on the index and yearly averages are compared to gain insight into the development of SRQ over the years. The content analysis covers reports for the years 2012-2021 published by 52 Finnish listed companies. The regression analysis is intended to complement the results of the content analysis. It controls for time, industry, size, profitability, and experience. The results are analysed from the perspective of legitimacy theory. Legitimacy theory assumes that a corporation has a need to justify its existence and place in society by gaining and maintaining societal acceptance, i.e. legitimacy. The theory has two layers: strategic and institutional legitimacy theory. Both perspectives are acknowledged in the discussion of this thesis because of the changing institutional landscape. The results confirm a pre-existing positive trend in SRQ. However, the higher increase in quality from before the NFRD (2016) to after the NFRD (2017) in comparison to other yearly intervals does suggest a positive correlation between mandatory sustainability reporting and sustainability reporting quality, which is in line with previous research. Insights from institutional legitimacy theory gain importance once regulation is introduced. The SRQ development appears to slow down after the introduction of regulation. Suggested future research includes exploring reasons behind this observation.
Author: Strandén, Isabella
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7115345719
Cites: 66
Cited by:
Related to: 10