Work

A Virtual Environment-Based Measure for Executive Functions and Prospective Memory : A Way to Bridge the Gap Between Objective and Subjective Cognitive Measures?

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The relations between objective (i.e., tests) and subjective measures (i.e., questionnaires) of prospective memory (PM) and executive functions (EFs) have often been weak, suggesting a lack of ecological validity of the conventional objective measures. This could potentially be remedied by new objective virtual environment based measures that simulate real-life EF and/or PM challenges. In the current study, I explored the ecological validity of Executive Performance in Everyday LIving (EPELI), a virtual environment-based task tapping EFs and PM, in an adult sample. Child EPELI performance has correlated significantly with subjective EF and PM measures, but in adults the associations have been much weaker or non-existent. As the earlier adult results were based on simple bivariate correlations, I revisited the issue by analyzing these adult data with multiple regression models. The participants included a neurotypical group (n = 255), and a group diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (n = 112). A selection of EPELI performance variables and conventional PM measures served as predictors, and questionnaires on everyday EF functioning or PM functioning as well as a journal on everyday PM challenges as dependent variables. None of the multiple regression models reached statistical significance, regardless of group. One possible reason for this null result in adults could lie in validity issues with the subjective measures of EFs and PM. Future researchers could analyze EPELI’s associations with real-life subjective measures of EFs and PM, or further develop the EPELI to provide more specific objective virtual environment-based measures of EFs and PM.
Author: Mäntysaari, Aino
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7115349421
Cites: 55
Cited by:
Related to: 9