Pseudoscience as Structural Disinformation: The Decoy Duck of Inquiry and Public Understanding of Science
Year: 2025
Type: preprint
Abstract: Pseudoscientific movements in health, climate and related domains shape how publics understand scientific evidence and expertise, yet they fit uneasily within standard definitions of misinformation and disinformation. Intentionalist accounts focus on malicious deception, “information disorder” models on falsehood, intent and harm, and functional accounts on ignorance generation, but none explains how largely sincere pseudo-inquiry can function as disinformation over time. This article develops a teleological–etiological framework that treats pseudoscience as structural disinformation. It combines a Functional–Attitudinal–Doctrinal (FAD) lens with a hazard–intent model that classifies content by its expected impact on public knowledge (epistemic hazard) and by whether it is strategically deceptive. This yields a taxonomy distinguishing legitimate science, fraudulent disinformation and pseudoscience as non-fraudulent structural disinformation. The framework links demarcation debates with public understanding of science and suggests ways to analyse and counter science-related disinformation.
Authors: Ramin, Rambod, Hadi, Samadi, Shahla, Eslami
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7116971322
