Work

Studies categorized as “awaiting classification” in Cochrane systematic reviews: frequency, justifications and adequacy to the Cochrane Handbook

Year: 2019
Type: review
Abstract: Objectives: To identify the reasons for considering a study as an “awaiting classification study” (ACS) in Cochrane reviews and to propose a guidance for management and reporting the decision for encoding a study as an ACS. Study Design and Setting: A cross-sectional analysis of Cochrane reviews, conducted in the Universidade Federal de São Paulo (UNIFESP), Brazil. Methods: All Cochrane systematic reviews of interventions published in the issues 1 to 6/2019 of the Cochrane Library were assessed. The reviews were manually identified in the Cochrane Library website and its references were manually extracted by two independent authors and organized in a pre-established form. Disagreements in the selection and extraction process were solved by consulting a third researcher. The justifications to consider the classified studies as ACS were distributed in 13 distinct categories. Results: We included 260 Cochrane reviews that classify the study 426 as ACS. The categories more frequently observed to classify the study as ACS were: no sufficient information to include or to exclude (111, 26.06%), justification not reported/not clear (82, 19.25%), study completed but without published results (64, 15.02%) and full text unavailable (62, 14,56%). Other alleged reasons were more infrequent. A guide for authors, reviewers and editors of systematic reviews was proposed to facilitate and make the process of classification more transparent. A checklist was also proposed and may be useful to manage and report ACS in future reviews. We suggested reasons for considering a study an ACS and proposed a checklist that may be useful to proper manage and report ACS in future reviews. Conclusion: The findings of this study showed that the main justification to categorize the studies as ACS were often inadequate or underreported by the review authors. This can be considered a shortcoming that compromise the transparency, reliability and reproducibility of Cochrane reviews. The adoption of a standardized checklist may be an initial strategy to improve this scenario. Future actions are warranted to better understand the impact of ACS in Cochrane systematic reviews and other systematic reviews.
Language: Portuguese
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7120720087
FWCI:
Cites: 42
Cited by:
Related to: 9