Work

Would Have Remembered II

Year: 2025
Type: study-registration
Abstract: This study will be a follow-up to previous pre-registration within this project (see the description of "Would Have Remembered I" for detailed background). There, we introduced an extended version of the Remember/Know (RK) paradigm to investigate the potential contribution of experiences of subjective memorability to the subsequent memory for items correctly rejected during an initial test. More specifically, during the initial test (Test 1), subjects were required to make a yes/no ‘Remember?’ (R) decision for items endorsed as old, whereas they were required to make a yes/no ‘Would Have Remembered?’ (WHR) decision for those endorsed as new. For the latter response, subjects were instructed to respond yes if they rejected the items because they failed to remember them yet believed the features of the items, because of their distinctiveness, would have triggered remembering if they had been studied. This study yielded three important findings: 1- Rejected items classified as +WHR in Test 1 were more likely to be successfully recognized in Test 2 with higher confidence than -WHR items, providing further support for our subjective memorability/distinctiveness hypothesis. 2- Item analyses showed that items claimed as subjectively memorable when not previously studied also yielded claims of remembering when studied. For each word, we calculated the rate at which it was claimed as subjectively memorable when it served as a lure and the rate at which it was claimed as remembered when it served as a target. These rates were reliably correlated across items, indicating participants have insight into the features that, when studied, are likely to lead to subsequent remembering. 3- Different than what was predicted, source memory for items claimed to be +WHR in Test 1 was not significantly better than the items claimed to be -WHR. Our analysis suggested that this null effect could a high bias towards “new” source responding, since the tendency to claim items were ‘new’ in a prior test was also high during Test 2 false alarms. The current study aims to address the bias issue for the source memory response by adding an additional response option for the source question, “I don’t know”. Giving people the option to say “I don’t know” will possibly control for the response bias that is possibly driving the obtained source memory results in the previous study.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7124159528
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10