Work

Protective factors for mental health of adolescents with and without experience of childhood adversity: A genetically sensitive approach

Type: dissertation
Abstract: The prevalence of mental health difficulties amongst children and young people is reported to have increased over recent years. Protective factors could provide a modifiable way of preventing and alleviating mental health difficulties, for adolescents with and without experience of childhood adversity. However, there is a lack of research into community level factors using prospective measurement of adversity and methods which can account for genetic and environmental confounding. This thesis aimed to enhance understanding of familial and community-level protective factors for adolescent mental health and wellbeing, both in the presence and absence of childhood adversity. This research comprises three analytical chapters, each exploring unique protective elements. The first study investigated whether a warm and supportive adult presence could be protective against mental health difficulties in adolescents who had experienced adverse childhood experiences (ACEs). Utilising data from the Environmental Risk (E-Risk) Longitudinal Twin Study, a twin-difference design was employed to explore whether within-pair differences in maternal warmth or adult support were associated with fewer mental health difficulties. Findings challenged existing phenotypic research, suggesting that the observed relationships between these factors were largely attributable to genetic and environmental confounding. The subsequent chapters analysed data from the Millennium Cohort Study (MCS), a nationally representative cohort study of young people in the UK. These studies focussed on investigating the role of several community level protective factors. The second study investigated the associations between community leisure activities and adolescent mental health outcomes, and whether this differed depending on experience of childhood adversity or demographic factors (gender and socioeconomic position). Of the activities studied, watching live sport was associated with better mental health outcomes, as was religious activity when maintained long term. Other activities were not found to be associated with fewer mental health problems, and no difference was found for experience of adversity or demographics. The third study focused on the protective effect of social support on internalising problems in adolescence, utilising polygenic scores (PGSs) to account for genetic confounding, as well as exploring if the association differed depending on experience of ACEs. Results indicated a protective effect of social support on adolescent internalising problems after accounting for genetic and environmental confounding. No difference was found by ACEs. Overall, this thesis provides insights into the existence of genetic and environmental confounding in the associations between several protective factors and mental health outcomes, using a range of methodologies. Findings suggest that social support may be protective against adolescent mental health outcomes, however adult support and community leisure activities do not seem to offer consistent protective effects. Implications of these findings for policy, practice and future research are discussed.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7125760634
Cites: 229
Cited by:
Related to: 9