Current performance and future potential of youth elite-level football players : insights from both objective data and subjective coach assessments
Year: 2025
Type: conference-abstract
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Background. Football clubs focus on developing homegrown talent using objective and subjective assessments to decide which players move within academies towards professional levels. However, the relationship between these objective and subjective measures used in practice remains understudied. Aim. This study aimed to investigate associations between objective performance variables and subjective performance and potential scores and to determine player profiles more likely to receive subjective ratings. Methods. 357 male elite youth football players (9 to 14 years) completed a test battery of anthropometric, physical performance, technical performance, and motor coordination assessments. Coaches rated players’ current performance and future potential using a visual analogue scale (0–100). First, univariable and multivariable mixed-effects linear regression models were used to analyze the association between subjective (outcome) and objective scores. Secondly, players were clustered based on objective performance characteristics by K-Nearest Neighbour clustering, VAS-based quadrants (1), and risk matrix classifications (2). Subjective and objective performance was described by cluster. Results. A strong correlation emerged between performance and potential ratings (r=0.70). Better physical performance (i.e., faster sprint, higher jumps, and better agility) was associated with better subjective ratings for both performance and potential. Multivariable models identified the 30m sprint as a key predictor for both performance (estimate [95% CI]: 4.04 [1.27, 6.79]) and potential (6.27 [2.90, 9.63]). Players with performance and potential scores above 50 showed better results on all physical performance tests than their peers with scores below 50. Players with performance and potential scores above 66, had better sprint, agility, and jumping sideways performance (all p<0.028) compared to those in the middle range (performance and potential scores >33 and ≤66). Conversely, players with the lowest performance and potential were shorter and performed worse on all physical performance tests than the middle-range group (all p<0.046). Conclusions. These findings highlight a strong association between subjective ratings and objective physical performance, particularly sprinting ability, while other critical player characteristics may be overlooked. Relying heavily on subjective ratings might introduce bias and limit the identification of diverse talent profiles with potential for future success. Therefore, a thoughtful integration that leverages the strengths of both knowledge sources to reinforce each other mutually is essential.
Language: English
Subfield: Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7130627023
