Retrospective of the Dynamic and Evolutive Interpretation of Echr: Framing the Strasbourg’s Interpretative Ethic
Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: Through the years of jurisprudence, the European Court of Human Rights has developed a quite unique and interesting dynamic and evolutive interpretation of ECHR. Starting from the Tyrer case, the Court has shaped the Convention using the doctrine of ‘living instrument’ and till today it has shown the capacity to evolve in the light of social and technological developments, and more importantly, to adapt its opinion on important Convention's rights. This paper will try, first of all, to explain the distinction between dynamic and evolutive interpretation of ECHR by giving an answer to new facts and giving new answers to old facts. Further, it will make a retrospective of the cases in which the Court gave dynamic or evolutive interpretation explaining that the 'ECHR is a living instrument which should be interpreted in present-day conditions'. Finally, the paper will discuss the latest developments concerning the ECHR’s interpretation, the criticism of being too narrow and morally ethic and the justification, for example in the case of Selmouni v. France, where the Court reiterates from its judgment delivered in the case of Ireland v. the United Kingdomexplaining that ‘certain acts which were classified in the past as inhuman and degrading treatment as opposed to torture could be classified differently in future. Perhaps this could mean that in future the Court should look beyond present conditions and condemn such acts more gravely thus becoming a true modern developer of the Convention's rights.
Source: Iustinianus Primus Law Review
Author: Stefanovska, Vesna
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7131019328
