Work

New Immigration and Images of the Americas: The Effects of Travel Writing in Hungary

Type: other
Abstract: Migration studies usually focus on economic, social and political considerations as the key “pull factors” influencing people’s decisions on finding a new home. Thus, for example, during the period of the New Immigration studied here, the United States is often presented as the primary destination for new immigrants because of the on-going (second) industrial revolution, technological developments, and a modern (and model) political system – all of which provide job opportunities and social freedom. Latin America compares poorly: “Political instability in several new Republics; the low demand for free labour in the majority of Latin American countries who possessed either large native populations (Mexico) or used slaves (Brazil and Cuba); the high cost of the passage; unfavourable geographies and climates in the hinterland; unattractive political and cultural characteristics; all help to explain why Latin America lagged well behind the United States as a destination for immigrants.” Yet as Puskás argues, “numerous other factors also played their part in the mechanism of emigration, factors not so much economic but rather social and psychological in nature, and these by and large elude quantification”. These include published accounts of earlier travellers and migrants published in the form of books, newspaper articles, and letters, whose descriptions of foreign lands could complement, contradict or exaggerate the traditional pull factors and thus influence migration patterns. This is especially important where political and cultural characteristics addressed by writers line up with the purposes of their accounts and their cultural background, personality and political stance. This literature played a key role in establishing the images of certain countries and its peoples, becoming reference points later on. It provided a general overview of the population, culture, political system and economy of the countries visited. The reports emigrants sent back also had a crucial impact on how attractive a country appeared. Their accounts make up a special part of the corpus of travel writing as their perceptions differ significantly from those travellers, tourists, or scientists who spent less time in the Americas. Emigrants discussed topics not addressed by others, often including descriptions of everyday life or tips for those considering emigration. Hungarian emigrants also sent private letters about their experience, often exaggerating the positive aspects of immigration. In what follows, I will study how accounts written by Hungarians reflected and shaped the images of the Americas and thus possibly migration patterns, providing an inter-American approach by focusing on the United States and Mexico. It is worth studying these two countries in comparison not only because of their geographical proximity but also because several Hungarians visited and wrote about both countries and often compared them, thus providing a ready-made case study of this phenomenon. For the United States, especially before the era of mass migration, travel accounts often exaggerated the positive features, while those written about Mexico focused on negative ones and discouraged migration. This changed at the beginning of the 20th century, when the United States closed its gates to new immigration and the Hungarian Government also attempted to discourage emigration, while Mexico during the Porfiriato (an era marked by the presidency of Porfirio Díaz, 1876/1884–1911) presented itself as an alternative. Travel accounts reflect the shift, but it was not enough (partly due to the outbreak of World War I) to change the overall images of the countries and thus fundamentally alter migration routes. As noted above, travel accounts are less-quantifiable influencing forces than other factors usually considered in migration studies, thus we need to be aware of certain limitations in terms of their significance. As Wendy Bracewell also notes, “the importance of the genre in shaping its readers’ views of the world is often assumed. The problem, as usual with the history of reading, is one of evidence for travel writing’s wider influence.” We cannot be certain of how many people actually read an account, whether they shared the perceptions of the traveller or not, and how they compared to other factors shaping people’s views of certain countries. Despite the lack of direct evidence on its influencing force, however, the role of travel writing as a source of information on foreign lands seems to be undisputed. We may identify recurring patterns and general trends that were shared by most people and made up an important part of knowledge on the countries studied here. Thus when studying the travel accounts written by Hungarians about the Americas in this paper, the texts are seen as reflections of the time and shapers of the discourse on migration, but by no means are they presented as decisive on their own when considering decisions of people on when, how and where to immigrate. They exerted their effect in combination with economic trends, governmental policies and general perceptions of the mother country and the New World shaped by various other texts simultaneously.
Language: English
Subfield: History
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132415230
Cites: 11
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10