Year: 2023
Type: report
Abstract: This study explores the perceived occupational safety and health risks involved in food delivery work in different operating environments, for example platform work and equivalent work, in trade and transport operating environments.Ten food courier service workers, eleven food delivery workers and ten food delivery supervisors and managers were interviewed.Data were analysed using qualitative thematic analysis.Findings show that significant challenges exist in terms of occupational safety and health risks for those who work on food delivery platforms.Those working in salaried food delivery jobs perceive more occupational wellbeing than platform workers do.Risks of traffic accidents are seen as high, and these are increased more by the time pressure involved in gig work.Workers of the food delivery companies find algorithmic management practices and working alone to be burdensome.Some also experience racist insults whilst working.There are deficits in the supervisory and communal support structures of the courier work.The most pervasive shortcoming is related to the precarious status of food couriers with temporary residence permits, as this often poses a significant barrier to their access to social security.The entanglements of platform work with the external institutional systems, such as the residency institution, are a key issue.These entanglements should be studied more, preferably across different country settings.Ensuring the equal treatment of platform workers in the Finnish labour market requires adjustments in both legislation and its enforcement.Subcontracting amongst food couriers, related monitoring and inspection practices and informal work within the sector are topics needing urgent attention. TiivistelmäTutkimushanke selvittää ruokajakelutyön koettuja riskejä erilaisissa toimintaympäristöissä.Tutkimuksen painopiste on alustatyön riskien ja työsuojelun tilanteen erittelyssä, ja sen rinnalla tarkastellaan vastaavaa työtä kaupan ja kuljetuksen toimintaympäristöissä.Hanke haastatteli kymmentä ruokalähettiä, yhtätoista kaupan ja kuljetuksen ruokajakelutyöntekijää ja kymmentä ruokajakelun esimiestä ja johtajaa.Aineistoa analysoitiin laadullisen teema-analyysin avulla.Ruuanjakelun palkkatyöläiset kokivat työhyvinvointinsa parempana kuin alustatyön ruokalähetit.Työturvallisuuden ja -terveyden haasteet ovat huomattavia alustatyönä tehtävässä ruokajakelussa.Liikenteen vaarat koetaan mittaviksi, ja keikkatyön aikapaine kasvattaa niitä.Osa ruokaläheteistä kokee algoritmisen johtamisen käytännöt ja yksintyöskentelyn psyko-sosiaalisesti kuormittavina.Ruokajakelun alustatyössä koetaan myös rasistisia loukkauksia, ja työnohjaukselliset sekä yhteisölliset tukirakenteet ovat osittain puutteellisia.Laajamittaisin haavoittuvuus liittyy tilapäisellä oleskeluluvalla olevien ruokalähettien epävarmaan asemaan.Maahanmuuttajataustaisilta itsensä työllistäjiltä puuttuu usein sellainen työoikeudellinen asema, joka turvaisi pääsyn sosiaaliturvaan.Alustatyön yhteyttä ulkoisiin institutionaalisiin järjestelmien, kuten oleskelulupajärjestelmään, tulisi tutkia enemmän, mieluiten vertailemalla eri maita.Yhdenvertaisuuden varmistaminen työmarkkinoilla edellyttää toimia lainsäätäjältä ja säädösten toimeenpanijoilta.Ruokalähettityön ulkoistusten ja niiden valvonnan sekä alan epävirallisen työn tutkiminen ovat kiireisimpiä aiheita jatkotutkimukselle.5 2. BACKGROUND This chapter consists of three sections: Section 2.1 introduces the development of food delivery services.Section 2.2 explains why and how food delivery forms an important case to understand OSH in relation to the change of work.Section 2.3 presents relevant legal cases and disputes in the area. Development of food delivery servicesSame-day food and grocery delivery services have been growing as a result of expansion of fast and accessible mobile internet (IGD, 2019), and the role of smartphones has become critical for the development of the food delivery industry (Order Meal, 2022).Furthermore, the COVID-19 pandemic, with individuals avoiding contacts, boosted the popularity of food delivery services (Perkiö et al., 2020).Each market has large-scale platform companies serving a rapidly growing customer base.In Finland, two main online delivery platforms dominate the local market: Foodora Oy (owned by Delivery Hero, based in Germany) and Wolt Oy (a Helsinki based technology company).Wolt is owned by US company Doordash that purchased the former in a 7-billion-euro deal that was the most expensive takeover in Europe' s rapid delivery market and the second largest corporate transaction in Finland' s business history (Lee & Kruppa, 2021; YLE News, 2022).Before the emergence of digital platforms, restaurants typically had their own delivery personnel, or restaurant staff members performed delivery services.A similar model was used in some grocery stores or chains.In 2003, Gastronautti launched food delivery operations in Helsinki, Tampere and Turku, accepting orders over phone; however, it filed for bankruptcy in 2007 (Tuppurainen, 2007).The brand existed for a few more years, mostly focusing on deliveries of groceries from grocery stores (Hakkarainen, 2015).Since 2007, the restaurant 'aggregator' Pizza-online brought together pizza and ethnic food delivery by the restaurants offering food deliveries in Finland.In 2012, the German online food delivery service Delivery Hero acquired the Finnish 'aggregator' Pizza-online and soon merged it into its platform Foodora.Restaurants in the premium service pay 16-22% of the price plus value added tax (VAT) as a commission for the online ordering service.The restaurants organise the delivery themselves (Toivonen & Björksten, 2019).The 'aggregator' model in Finland and other countries usually offered customers an opportunity to see and compare menus from different restaurants, read and write reviews and place orders.The restaurants could get new customers and better visibility from 'aggregators' through additional marketing channel (Hirschberg et al., 2016).Wolt was established in 2014 in Helsinki and, by fall 2021, it operated in 23 countries and, in 27 towns of Finland.In 2021, over 100,000 delivery workers were registered with Wolt globally and over 4,000 in Finland alone (Halonen & Pikkarainen, 2020).However, the platform company globally has only 3,600 formal employees -mostly in IT and support roles.Foodora was launched in Helsinki in 2015 and while writing this report operates in 20 towns in Finland, Sweden and Norway.It is owned by the multinational company Delivery Hero that operates in over 50 countries globally.In Finland, Foodora reported that it works with over 2,000 delivery partners with their number constantly growing (Halonen & Pikkarainen, 2020).Foodora and Wolt are estimated to be equal in size in Finland (Raeste, 2020).Differing from Finland' s contractor-based model, in Norway, approximately 40% of food couriers are employees and the rest are contractors.In Norwegian big cities, riders may choose between these options.There is a collective agreement between the trade union and the company regulating bicycle food delivery (Eurofound, 2021).
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: occupational health and safety, food delivery workers, platform work, gig work, algorithmic management, traffic accidents, precarious employment, temporary residence permits, social security access, workplace racism, working alone, subcontracting, informal employment, equal treatment, labor market regulation, Finland, employee well-being, occupational stress
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132878146
