Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The goal of science education is to teach children scientific content and develop their reasoning skills. Children enter school with early prior beliefs that can interfere with the acquisition of scientific knowledge. This dissertation investigated how adults can support scientific inquiry in domains in which children have erroneous prior beliefs. Support was provided through (1) guidance – explicit adult scaffolds – that facilitated children in designing and reflecting on evidence and (2) explanations that aided their interpretations of the concept. This work examined how guidance and explanations both individually and in combination fostered kindergarteners’ science understanding and skills. Findings in Chapter 2 showed that kindergarteners revised their understanding that objects of different weights fall at the same rate. Although guidance alone helped children create and evaluate anomalous evidence, leading to more accurate predictions (Experiment 1), guidance only affected children’s short-term understanding. Children did not maintain this understanding after a delay (Experiment 2). Combining explanations with guidance led to better understanding and long-term retention. Furthermore, children generalized and transferred this understanding to objects with the same weight. Findings in Chapter 3 demonstrated that kindergarteners learned from conceptual information when combined with low and high guided activities. However, the degree of autonomy that children had within the activities influenced the extent of their learning. Explanations combined with guidance from an adult (high-guidance) led to increased understanding and retention of content. In comparison, children who heard an explanation and then participated in exploratory activities with low-guidance showed less learning and retention. Notably, children’s understanding varied as a function of science concept for the exploratory condition. This dissertation is among the first to systematically examine the influence of guidance and explanations on young children's scientific understanding where they have robust prior beliefs. The findings (1) affirm the value of explanations in building knowledge about complex science concepts; (2) show how adult guidance makes tasks more age-appropriate and contributes to the production of counterevidence; and (3) advocates the conclusion that each factor can have separate effects. Thus, adults should offer both types of supports for optimal science learning to foster long-term scientific understanding.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132897747
