Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The importance of usable privacy and security is growing as technologies are rapidly advancing and becoming more widely adopted.The balance between usability, privacy, and security has been a long debated topic, as enhancing usability is often seen to compromise the privacy and security of the device, and vice versa.However, it is important to find a balance where privacy and security aspects are designed with user-friendly solutions to prevent user errors and ensure effective use.In the realm of wearable technology, smartwatches have become a significant part of the global wearables market, with their popularity increasing rapidly during recent years.Despite the ongoing research on the technical and security aspects of smartwatches, there is a gap in studies focusing on usable privacy and security features on those devices.This thesis aims to bridge this gap by examining the usability, privacy, and security features specific to smartwatches.The main objectives of this thesis are to explore the current state of privacy and security features on smartwatches and propose design recommendations for improvement.The objectives are achieved by understanding the theoretical background of the research field and collecting data using two different research methods: the system evaluation of smartwatch and online survey from smartwatch users.For the empirical part of the thesis, the Apple Watch was chosen as the context due to its extensive user base and advanced technological capabilities.Its privacy and security features were evaluated through a system evaluation, which included assessing the setup process, pre-installed apps, the effectiveness of privacy and security settings, and the backup files.Additionally, an online survey was conducted with Apple Watch users, which consisted of both closed questions and open-ended questions, the latter enabling the collection of qualitative material to deepen the understanding of users' perceptions and opinions.As a result of this research, key findings and design recommendations were identified regarding the privacy and security of Apple Watches and the perceptions of their users, based on research methods and comparisons to prior work.One of the main findings highlighted a security weakness, revealing that all sensitive data on the Apple Watch is accessible without required passcode protection unless the Wallet application is used.Furthermore, the study showed that the configuration of some privacy and security settings is skipped during the setup process, leaving users unaware of all available options.Additionally, a short four-digit passcode is indicated as the standard option for users during setup, aligning with the result that most users do not prefer longer passcodes for their smartwatches.The study also revealed that privacy and security settings are scattered across various categories in the Apple Watch settings menu making them difficult to locate.Furthermore, results showed that users also expressed unwillingness to modify settings due to a lack of motivation, awareness, or trust in the service provider.In response to these findings, the thesis presents design recommendations to tackle these security and usability issues.These recommendations focus on enhancing passcode protection, improving the organization of settings, and ensuring that users are adequately informed and motivated to manage their privacy and security settings.By addressing the identified issues and implementing the proposed recommendations, smartwatch manufacturers can better meet user needs, thereby increasing both user satisfaction and security.
Author: Mäkelä, Maria
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132902912
