Work

The Empathy Selection Task: Evaluating Empathy as a Subjective Value-based Choice

Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Empathy often feels automatic, but variations in empathic responding suggest that, at least some of the time, empathy is affected by one’s motivation to empathize in any particular circumstance. Here, I investigate a novel free-choice behavior measure of motivated empathy avoidance called the empathy selection task. First, I assess the suitability of the empathy selection task for use in individual difference and experimental research by examining its reliability within and across testing sessions, and by examining rank order stability of summary scores (Studies 1a and 1b). The empathy selection task is stable between testing sessions and has good/substantial test-retest reliability (ICCs = .65 and .67), suggesting that it is comparable or superior to other commonly used experimental tasks with respect to its ability to consistently rank individuals. Next, I show that people can be motivated to engage in (or avoid) empathy-eliciting situations with strangers, and that these decisions are driven by subjective value-based estimations of the costs (e.g., cognitive effort) and benefits (e.g., social reward) inherent to empathizing. Participants were more likely to opt into empathy-eliciting situations if 1) they were incentivized monetarily for doing so (Studies 2a and 2b), and 2) if a more familiar and liked empathy target was available (Studies 3a and 3b). Framing empathy as explicitly related to one’s moral character and reputation did not motivate participants to engage in empathy (Studies 4a and 4b), though these null results may be due to a weak manipulation. These findings suggest that empathy can be motivated in multiple ways, and that context-specific value-based decision can be captured and measured by the empathy selection task.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132912600
Cites: 136
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10