Year: 2007
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Traditional approaches to the study of children's compliance have focused on a uni-dimensional construct, with compliance at one end of the spectrum and noncompliance at the other. Given the clinical implications of excessive non-compliance in young children, such efforts have been justified; however, some theorists suggest that non-compliance is a normative part of children's development, and that compliance should be balanced with autonomous behaviour for healthy development (e.g. Spitz, 1957). Within the last decade, some researchers (e.g. Kuczynski and colleagues) have focused their investigations on the various expressions that young children's noncompliance takes in non-clinical samples. In the present study, predictive features of the different forms of non-compliance, such as the child's age, sex, and type of request were explored; relationships between non-compliance strategies and three aspects of maternal responsivity were also examined. During the year 2004, seventy-five 9 to 11 year-old children and their mothers took part; families had previously participated three years prior, at which time, various aspects of parenting were assessed. At the follow up, parenting was measured again, in addition to children's non-compliance strategies. Predictions were made regarding the frequency of each type of non-compliance. The current study found that 9 to 11 year-olds use the same strategies---namely, passive non-compliance, justification/negotiation, and negativistic non-compliance---as younger children studied in other research programs. As expected, children clearly used skilled forms of non-compliance such as justification/negotiation frequently and rarely used unskilled forms such as negativism. Although some discrepancies were observed, there was also evidence that both delay and passive non-compliance are common among children in this age range. Hypotheses concerning the relations between the child's age, sex, the type of request, and the forms of non-compliance were also posited. Although the initial predictions were not met, the current study uncovered interesting findings regarding the nature of the request and types of non-compliance, with the results suggesting that children do select particular types of non-compliance as a function of the type of request. Sex effects were found for passive non-compliance, and age and sex interactions were observed for delay, with the findings generally indicating that boys' use of delay increases with age, whereas girls showed an inverted U-shaped trend. Contrary to expectation, however, there was no support for age and sex differences in negativism and justification/negotiation. Lastly, maternal responsiveness to distress appeared to be the most relevant aspect of responsiveness affecting children's use of passive noncompliance and justification/negotiation. In addition, maternal warmth was a predictor of children's delay. Authoritative responsiveness did not contribute to children's noncompliance strategies. The implications of these findings are discussed.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Awong, Tsasha Schlawn
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132944189
