Work

Transformation of Self and Meaning: An Exploration of Arts-Based Critical Episodes Narratives

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Self-understanding, transformation, actualization, and transcendence are aspirational goals. Interaction between internal (personal) and external (contextual) factors, shape individuals’ lived experiences, and derived self-understanding. Self-analysis (reflection) and self-disclosure (expression), integral for meaning making, have been traditionally explored through discursive means. These are inherently limited processes, as they are dependent on one’s developmental, linguistic, and/or cognitive capabilities. Artistic creation and appreciation, however, are non-discursive means of reflection and expression, which leverage the multisensory insights of embodied experience. Arts-Based Research (ABR) supports the exploration of personal knowledge building, meaning, and development through the transdisciplinary study of arts-based experience. The Art-Based Critical Episodes Method (ACE) is an exploratory participatory ABR method, rooted in the Adapted Embodied Hermeneutic process. It explores arts-based experience through a transformative narrative process. The method boasts a person-centered, phenomena-focused, process-oriented, and growth-driven approach. This project adopts a QUAL-quan exploratory mixed methods design, rooted in surface and deep structure narrative analyses (phenomenological, phenomenographic, and actantial analyses). The viability of the ACE is explored through the study of meaning, well-being, and self-transcendent wisdom in arts-based critical episode(s) narratives. The present research explores two potential variations of ACE (N = 33). The first study explores the viability of the method as a semi-structured interview, in a sample of professional performing artists (n = 12), engaged in remote co-creation of art. The second study applies the method in a self-initiated remote survey, in a general sample of participants, engaged in independent artistic creation (n = 21). Findings reveal three actantial patterns within individuals’ narratives; the patterns are indicative of one’s narrative (autobiographical reasoning) style, eudaimonic growth orientation, and self-transcendent wisdom. Exploratory reasoning results from appraisal of internal and external factors of a critical episode as helper and/or opponent, oscillating throughout the narrative. Heroic reasoning results from narrative transformation of factors, from opponent to helper; a positive form of cathartic transcendence of self and situation. Tragic reasoning results from negative narrative transformation of factors, from helper to opponent. These findings reveal a complex relationship between one’s arts-based embodied experience, reflection, and expression; suggesting that narrative transformation modulates personal meaning, well-being, and self-transcendent wisdom.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7133012591
Cites: 286
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10