Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation explores how organizations’ hiring practices intersect with economic opportunity, diversity, and social responsibility. The first chapter, Tearing the Paper Ceiling? Non-Degree Paths in Professional Jobs, examines how employers evaluate non-degree candidates based on alternative skill signals (such as years of relevant experience, employment at a prominent firm, micro-credentials), employers stated degree requirements, and candidates' demographic characteristics. Using a large-scale audit study of nearly 18,000 applications for software and marketing jobs, I found that alternative-routes candidates received 28% fewer callbacks than degree holders with the same experience, even when degree requirements were absent. However, this gap disappeared when non-degree candidates had twice the relevant experience. Other skill signals had minimal impact, suggesting that while employers recognize multiple pathways to skill acquisition, the absence of a degree remains a significant barrier across candidates career paths. The second chapter, Skill-Based Hiring: A Path to Better Matches and Greater Inclusion? explores how job seekers interpret skill-based hiring signals—such as eliminating degree requirements—across different educational backgrounds, racial groups, and gender. Drawing on job-seeking behavior research, I argue that these signals influence perceptions of job quality, organizational structure, and diversity commitments. These perceptions, in turn, may shape application behavior in ways that complicate the intended effects of skill-based hiring policies. The third chapter, Organizational Purpose as a Competitive Edge in Tight Labor Markets, examines how firms use organizational purpose—such as meaningful work and social responsibility—to attract talent. While research suggests job seekers value purpose-driven work, little is known about how firms strategically deploy these claims under labor market pressures. Using U.S. job postings from 2010 to 2021, I find that labor market tightness had little effect on firms’ use of purpose-driven messaging. However, firms that emphasized a mission beyond profit maximizing responded differently to competitive pressures, increasing wages by four percentage points more than others. These findings suggest that rather than using corporate purpose claims to lower labor costs, firms aligned these signals with higher compensation, mitigating the risks of appearing disingenuous.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Language: English
Topic: Employer Branding and e-HRM
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7133014798
