The effect of ALD coating composition on coating adhesion and in vitro degradation of orthopedic magnesium alloy implants
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Magnesium is a promising material for bioabsorbable orthopedic implants due to its mechanical properties close to those of bone, and biocompatibility. However, the degradation of magnesium-based implants in physiological conditions is fast and the degradation rate is difficult to predict. In addition, the degradation of magnesium causes hydrogen gas formation in the surrounding tissues, which might lead to tissue layer separation. To overcome these challenges, coatings for corrosion protection are developed. To ensure good corrosion protection properties, coating adhesion needs to be sufficient. Good coating adhesion is needed for the coating to stay firmly attached to the implant surface, therefore decreasing the risk of corrosive media penetration into the substrate. The aim of this work was to develop and perform coating adhesion testing for atomic layer deposition (ALD) coated magnesium-calcium-zinc alloy discs and orthopedic screws, and to compare the in vitro degradation rate and coating adhesion between three different coating compositions on the magnesium alloy samples. The studied ALD coating compositions were A, B, and C, with similar coating thickness. The most promising coating composition was determined based on in vitro and adhesion test results. A 26-week in vitro degradation test for coated magnesium alloy discs was performed in modified Hank’s buffer solution for all three coating compositions. At 2-week time point, the highest mass loss was observed with discs coated with coating C (comparable to the uncoated controls), whereas the discs coated with coatings A and B degraded slower. At 26-week time point, the results were the opposite. Therefore, coatings A and B seemed to effectively slow down the degradation at the beginning of the study, and coating C in long-term after the initial fast degradation. The coating adhesion testing of coated discs was performed by a tape test modified from standard ASTM D3359-23. All three coating compositions were studied both as sterilized and unsterile. No distinctive differences between the coating compositions or the state of sterility of the coating were observed. However, only <1 % of coating was detached during testing for all samples, indicating good coating adhesion. The test method was evaluated functional based on the consistent results obtained from parallel samples. Next, the coating adhesion of coated orthopedic screws was tested. Coating compositions B and C were selected for the coating adhesion testing of coated screws. The adhesion test included coated screw insertion into artificial bone to mimic the conditions of a surgical operation. The test revealed that the coating was most vulnerable for detachment in the screw threads that were in contact with artificial bone. In the screw shaft, most of the coating was retained during testing. There were no clear differences in the coating adhesion between the two studied coating compositions. Based on the in vitro degradation and coating adhesion testing, the most promising coating for short-term corrosion protection was coating B, and for long-term protection, coating C. Short-term protection is more important in terms of orthopedic implant applications since after implantation, the mechanical properties of the implant need to be maintained long enough for the bone tissue to heal. The test methods provided important preliminary information of the ALD coating adhesion on magnesium alloy substrate. Based on the results in this work, ALD coatings are a promising option for slowing down the degradation of magnesium based orthopedic implants.
Author: Mäkinen, Lotta
Language: English
Subfield: Biomaterials
Field: Materials Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7133015416
