Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Listeners struggle to recognize talkers who speak in accents different than their own. This Other Accent Effect (OAE) has interesting implications for theories of human speech processing; it has also led to concerns about wrongful convictions due to voice misidentification in the court of law. Despite the theoretical and practical importance of the OAE, its mechanisms and origins are not well understood. In this dissertation, I use a voice line-up procedure to explore the OAE in three types of listener populations. In Chapter 2, I examine the role of processing ease and social markedness in talker recognition by native English-speaking adults. While my planned analyses did not provide evidence to support processing ease or sociolinguistic attitudes as primary explanations for the OAE, exploratory analyses leave open the possibility that processing ease may still play a role in the OAE. In Chapter 3, I assess how accent familiarity influences the presence of the OAE by comparing native (L1) and non-native (L2) English-speaking listeners’ recognition of the same set of talkers. We observe that L2 listeners also struggle to recognize L2 talkers even if they share the same L2 accent. This suggests that the OAE with L2 accents may result from inconsistencies in L2 speech productions that may obscure the identification of L2 talker differences. The findings of this study also lead us to question whether the ‘Other’ in the Other Accent Effect might be a bit of a misnomer. And finally, in Chapter 4, I report the first study to investigate the developmental trajectory of the OAE. This large-scale study asks how the recognition of own- and other-accented talkers, as well as sociolinguistic attitudes, might change during mid to late childhood. My findings demonstrate that the OAE is already well-entrenched in 6-year-olds, but not yet adult-like. As with the adult listeners in Chapter 2, children’s developing social biases did not appear to influence performance. Together, these findings further our understanding of the interdependent nature of the use of linguistic and indexical information in speech processing and provide valuable insights for improving practices in legal settings, especially concerning voice identifications in court.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Yu, Madeleine
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7133063259
