A Psychodynamic Approach to Assisting Individuals who Struggle with Obsessionality and Compulsivity
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The aim of this thesis is to demonstrate a valid role for contemporary psychodynamic psychotherapy (CPP) in assisting people struggling with obsessionality and compulsivity – most commonly termed obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD). The question I set out to explore is whether such a possibility can be supported by the relevant literature. OCD is a severely disabling and essentially chronic condition that affects approximately one in fifty people in their lifetime. There is no cure for OCD. The prescribed and mandated treatment for it - exposure with response prevention, with or without psychotropic medication (ERP) - is of limited effectiveness for a significant proportion of people seeking help. For approximately 10% of those seeking help, it is not effective at all. Rather than exploring alternate approaches to treatment, these people are classified ‘treatment resistant’. As I define it, ‘CPP’ includes contemporary psychoanalysis as one of its many expressions; characteristics they share include the turn to a two-person psychology, an emphasis on emotion, work with unformulated experience and implicit process, recognition of the healing power of the therapeutic relationship itself, and an interest in trauma and dissociation. The status of OCD as a ‘disorder’ is questionable as it may not be a unitary entity; there are no biological markers for the condition, and the term invites inappropriate medicalisation of problems in living. It is nevertheless employed throughout this thesis, to conform with common usage and to avoid confusion. A preferred conceptualisation is ‘individuals who struggle with obsessionality and compulsivity’. The importance of the topic to the field lies in the possibility of enhancing the effectiveness of clinical work with OCD, and of rectifying indifference towards those who have fallen through the cracks of current research practices, theory, and orthodox treatment. The research design relies on professional books and peer-reviewed journals as data sources. Texts have been selected through a process of manual snowballing, supplemented by citation network analysis. The design is guided by Gadamerian hermeneutics, a theory of understanding rather than method, with its worth resting not on its demonstrable ‘truth’ but on the extent to which it suggests practical utility. However, the thesis is not an exercise in hermeneutics requiring a hermeneutic conclusion. Convergence and conjunctions between psychodynamic understandings of OCD and CPP are explored, as a basis for proposing the potential for a CPP approach to clinical work with OCD. The key understanding is that the observed and phenomenological characteristics of OCD are underpinned by core fears, and that such fears may be resolved or managed with CPP. While ERP is aimed at symptom reduction, and may rely on unique neurological change processes, it is suggested that it may work in part because experienced practitioners have long been employing skills that are part of psychodynamic theory and practice. Better understanding and more conscious use of such skills may lead to increased effectiveness. Additionally, CPP has the demonstrable potential to provide a treatment paradigm that is different in kind, and parallel, and complementary to, orthodox treatment models, thus enhancing assistance to individuals who struggle with obsessionality and compulsivity. The outlining of such a potential is a major contribution to the field.
Author: Barnaby, John
Institution: Charles Sturt University
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7133091669
