Unpacking Women's Recreational Spaces: Feminist Perspectives on Recreational Inequality in the Urban Peripheries of Kolkata - Insights from the Pilot Study
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: This pilot study explores how the invisibility of the spatial practices of ordinary women from disadvantaged backgrounds, often considered subaltern, in the urban peripheries of Indian cities perpetuates recreational inequality, with Kolkata as a case study. It aims to understand how the recreational practices and everyday spatial landscapes of subaltern women living under precarious conditions in peripheral, quasilegal settlements have been marginalized in mainstream recreational policies, shaped by upper-middleclass, male-centered approaches in neoliberal Indian cities. Drawing on Lefebvre’s (1976) concept of the production of space and feminist perspectives on contextspecific, subjective meaning-making processes related to recreation (Henderson, 1996; Mohanty, 1988, 2003)we investigate what recreation means to subaltern women and their associated everyday spaces, offering preliminary insights into their everyday recreational landscape. We adopt a participatory ethnographic approach across three contrasting peri-urban neighborhoods in Kolkata to challenge “World-Class City” initiatives that frame recreation as free-time activity in homogenized formal public spaces like parks and commercial places. These policies consider surveillance and aesthetic upgrades as a homogenized planning and design need for women-friendly spaces, while failing to acknowledge grassroots-level knowledge and lived realities. Accessed through municipal connections, we conducted 15 semi-structured interviews through snowball sampling and analyzed them with a grounded theory approach. Findings show a comparative analysis of the three areas, revealing that subaltern women’s recreation is shaped by a nuanced interpretation of recreation associated with leisure, embedded in fragmented, everyday activities within informal, self-made spaces across five settings: residences, informal workplaces, neighborhood spaces, religious spaces, and child-centered spaces. Furthermore, these practices are influenced by socio-cognitive needs shaped by social roles, identity, norms, and agency specific to different groups and locations. The study concludes that subaltern women’s recreation is a contested space, where the physical characteristics of spaces require an in-depth understanding of context-specificity, local knowledge, and women-centered lived experiences.
Authors: Ankita Karmakar, Mallika Bose
Institution: Pennsylvania State University
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7134223222
