Work

Disability, disease, and dissent: embodiment as critique of British and American empire from the Stamp Act crisis to Manifest Destiny

Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: "Disability, Disease, and Dissent" demonstrates that the depiction of disability and illness seen in eighteenth and early nineteenth-century literature was integral to challenging the progressive narrative of imperialism advanced in both England and America. At a time when the healthy body represented the well-functioning body politic, the depiction of disabled and diseased bodies in literature proved a versatile trope capable of exposing the marginalization that continued within England and America even as they gained global preeminence. Benjamin Franklin developed a rhetoric of embodiment to establish an analogy between the imperial body politic and the human body. This rhetoric, analyzed in chapter one, permitted critique of British policy in the colonies, because depictions of abnormal bodies signaled problems with imperial policy. This practice was most evident during the Stamp Act protests of 1765, and remained viable throughout the Revolutionary and early republican period. Chapter two examines novels that capture the social marginalization of disabled veterans. In Royal Tyler’s The Contrast this pursuit highlights the way in which domestic norms conflicted with the attainment of benefits promised to disabled veterans. In Mansfield Park, the depiction of Mr. Price, a disabled veteran, resonates with a contemporary legal dispute involving negelect of disabled soldiers at Greenwich Hospital. Charles Brockden Brown’s Arthur Mervyn and Maria Edgeworth’s Belinda, the paired texts in chapter three, modify the traditional novel of development by focusing on disabled and diseased characters. In Brown’s novel, Arthur’s maturation departs from convention due to the disruptive effects of the yellow fever epidemic in Philadelphia in 1793. Rather than become a mature independent citizen, he marries an Englishwoman. Belinda shifts focus from the subject of the title character’s growth to focus on the diseased Lady Delacour, a woman wrongly diagnosed with breast cancer. While Belinda’s development stands to reinforce many domestic norms, Lady Delacour ultimately defines the domestic space and its norms as products of artifice. Chapter four reads Lydia Maria Child’s Hobomok (1824) and Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) as critiques of America’s westward expansion. Child critiques the viability of frontier expansion by identifying the sense of destined progress in her own time with the Puritan conviction that their settlement was divinely mandated. By depicting Puritan settlers as vulnerable to disease while presenting Natives as healthy and thriving, Child deflates the Puritan sense of destiny and thus undercuts the rationale for “Manifest Destiny” that emerged in the 1820s. Shelley similarly interrogates the ambitions of frontier settlers from the perspective of an English conservative wary of English migration to America. Her concern for American growth, like her concern for scientific hubris, is rooted in a disillusionment with exploitative practices that deny human interdependence. Shelley addresses biopolitical dilemmas by showing how a purely acquisitive mentality leads to the exhaustion of nature and the endangerment of human life. An afterword considers the emergence of the southern hemisphere as a locus of American imperialism.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7134711786
Cites: 135
Cited by:
Related to: 9