Work

Te Awa Tupua - Legal Personhood and Rights of Nature in Aotearoa New Zealand

Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Te Awa Tupua is the name given to the Whanganui River by Whanganui iwi. There is no direct translation of “Te Awa Tupua” into English, but Anne Salmond has explained that the name can be understood as “river with ancestral power”. The Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River Claims Settlement) Act 2017 (TATA) recognises Te Awa Tupua to be “an indivisible and living whole, comprising the Whanganui River from the mountains to the sea, incorporating all its physical and metaphysical elements”. TATA also recognises the inalienable connection between Whanganui iwi and the river: “Ko au te Awa, ko te Awa ko au: I am the river and the river is me”. Perhaps most intriguingly from a Western legal perspective, TATA declares that “Te Awa Tupua is a legal person and has all the rights, powers, duties and liabilities of a legal person”. Before Te Awa Tupua, the Te Urewera Act declared the legal personhood of Te Urewera (the homeland of Tūhoe),5 and these two entities have since been joined by Te Kāhui Tupua (representing Taranaki, Pouākai and the Kaitake Ranges). Each Treaty Settlement Act establishes a system of co-governance centred around what will be described in this thesis as a Natural Legal Person (NLP), which in turn represents and embodies relational values derived from and embedded in tikanga Māori. Since it was introduced, the legal personhood of Te Awa Tupua (and of the other Aotearoa NLPs to a more limited extent) has often been associated with the broader international discourse on the idea of rights of nature. The central objective of the thesis is to clarify the connection between TATA and rights of nature and, in the process, to suggest ways in which the novel legal personhood of Te Awa Tupua can be appropriately reconciled with certain basic preconceptions about rights in Western law. The tension between tikanga Māori and Western law can be traced back to fundamental ontological and axiological differences. Western law traditionally assumes a normative-moral standpoint of value-individualism, grounded in science and economics, and treating adjudication between the conflicting interests of human individuals as the core function of law. In contrast, tikanga Māori applies a more collective and relational set of values, grounded in mātauranga Māori and whanaungatanga. A core argument presented throughout the thesis is that reconciling the legal personhood of Te Awa Tupua and other Aotearoa NLPs with tikanga Māori requires the recognition of collective and relational values in Western law. There is both legal precedent and theoretical support for this recognition, but it cannot be taken for granted. Defaulting to a conventional Western understanding of individual property rights and corporate legal personality would contradict and undermine the text, purpose and spirit of the NLP Treaty Settlements.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7135259553
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10