Work

Working When It Doesn’t Fit - How Gender, Profession, and Organizational Size Moderate the Effect of Value-Discrepant Environments on Compassion and Occupational Hea

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Compassion is a fundamental aspect of effective healthcare that is mandated for physicians and expected by patients. Emerging evidence suggests that delivering healthcare services with compassion is associated with better outcomes for both patients and clinicians. However, despite its importance, compassion is not consistently present in healthcare settings. While prior studies have focused on physician and, to a lesser extent, patient and clinical factors, the influence of potentially scalable organizational factors on compassion remains comparatively underexplored. A single recent report in the area has suggested that perceived discrepancies between employer and healthcare worker values interfere with the ability to be compassionate and predict poorer occupational health outcomes (Pavlova et al., 2023). The current thesis extends this work, assessing whether the effects of value discrepancies on compassion ability, compassion competence, burnout, and job satisfaction vary across different subsets of the healthcare workforce. Specifically, it investigates whether the effects of value discrepancies are moderated by profession, gender, or organizational size. Using a pre-registered analytic plan, archival survey data from 1020 English-speaking doctors, nurses, and allied health professionals across New Zealand were tested. Participants provided demographic and job-related data before completing standardized measures of job satisfaction, burnout, compassion ability and competence, and value discrepancies. Contrary to pre-registered predictions, regression analyses showed no moderation effects on compassion competence, burnout, or job satisfaction – any effects associated with value discrepancies were consistent across groups. However, consistent with predictions, moderation effects emerged for compassion ability. Specifically, value discrepancies more strongly predicted lower compassion ability for females versus males, for doctors compared to nurses, and for individuals in smaller organizations compared to larger ones. In testing the generalizability of one of the few known organizational predictors of compassion in healthcare settings, this thesis offers a valuable extension to prior research. While value discrepancies consistently had negative effects on both patient-facing and occupational health outcomes, their effects were stronger in certain groups and settings. The presence of moderation tends to suggest that employees’ sensitivity to value discrepancies and their “proximity” to organizational decisional centres may be important. Such findings highlight both the occupational costs of value discrepancies and the importance of environmental factors in influencing compassion in healthcare.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7135773551
Cites: 188
Cited by:
Related to: 9