Critical teacher leadership as transformative professionalism: Inquiry and (inter)action via a methodological bricolage
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: The predominant focus of educational leadership research has largely fixated on an individualistic ‘heroic’ interpretation, emphasizing the solo actions exercised by those in formal positions of authority. This conceptualization, underpinning both research and praxis, has been problematized for being non-dialogical, reifying hierarchical power structures, and being both contradictory to and incongruent with social justice. To authentically enact meaningful social change in our educational institutions, it is essential to advance the emancipatory grassroots ‘bottom-up’ leadership initiatives of students, teachers, and corresponding community members. Utilizing a methodological bricolage, I co-engaged in participatory research methods alongside my teacher colleagues to co-facilitate various critical teacher leadership practices throughout the 2022/2023 school year. Through our dialogical (inter)actions, leadership initiatives manifested in a plethora of contexts to address varying situational needs (e.g., via critical pedagogies, committee work, mentorship, etc.). To interpret this phenomenon, I generated a novel conceptualization of critical teacher leadership drawing upon the distributed perspective on leadership, critical theory and emancipatory grassroots leadership, and transformative professionalism. Data collection and generation methods for this methodological bricolage included photoVOICE, individual and group reflection discussions, and a document analysis of Manitoba legislative, policy, and resource education documents. The thematic analysis of the textual transcriptions of these data sources revealed our perceptions on how critical teacher leadership practices positively impacted our school communities, empowered our own and others’ professional agency, and fostered student engagement and collegial relationships. However, we also navigated complex social and/or structural barriers that impeded our initiatives, including a sense of occupational isolation and silencing, invisibilization of leadership, (micro)aggressive collegial resistances, and feelings of exhaustion and demoralization. These findings illuminate how new insights into how critical teacher leadership intersects with the core tenets of transformative professionalism, practices predicated upon autonomy, exercising knowledge, activism, professional learning, collegial interactions, and ethical conduct. This study also generates new perspectives on the inherent tensions within teachers’ transformative professionalism, as teachers strive to advance their own individual agency and occupational autonomy through emancipatory leadership practices, but are simultaneously governed via organizational infrastructures.
Source: Mspace (University of Manitoba)
Author: Laidlaw, Jordan
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7137512275
