Work

Chapter Introduction

Year: 2020
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: drylands.The assumption was that drylands were 'low potential' areasunsuitable for farming -and thus were relegated as sites for investment.The prevailing notion was that pastoral land uses were destructive and inherently unproductive.Pastoralism as a way of life was and continues in many ways to be seen as outdated, backward and ill-fitting in a contemporary nation-state.The presence of central state power and corporate capital was previously minimal in such areas, but when state plans and capital investments arrived, new negotiations over rights and access unfolded.The recent land and resource rush thus upends established patterns of state-society relations in the drylands.No longer seen as threatening borderlands in need of pacification, or low potential wastelands that can be ignored, in public and policy imaginations these areas are now seen as frontiers with abundant land and resources that can be exploited for national wealth (Greiner 2016;Mosley and Watson 2016;Browne 2015).The land rush marks a moment of repositioning for pastoralist frontiers in national development strategies and economic planning.The shift is all the more notable when considering that it follows decades of underinvestment and marginalisation by post-colonial governments.Ports, pipelines, roads, wind farms and plantations are all linked in the 'high modernist' 2 visions of states and private capital (Ferguson 2005; cf.Scott 1998).Such large-scale investments are portrayed as part of wider commer cialisation and growth imperatives, and even as a precursor to peacebuilding and the creation of 'resilient' livelihoods for pastoralists (Smalley 2017; Nicol 2015).Yet investments come up against the reality of existing intricacies of social and economic practices, and embedded regional systems of marketing and trade; they are always therefore tentative, provisional and in the process of becoming realised (Enns et al. 2019;Stein and Kalina 2019).The colonial depiction of these places on maps as 'uninhabited' or 'wilderness' is updated in new frontier visions as expanses of land that are cheap and for sale, while ignoring overlapping claims to land and resources, based on ancestral precedence, communal histories and practices of making use of these environments over generations.Many influential actors are involved in the global investment push from international corporates to states and local elites, very often in interaction (Keene et al. 2015;Margulis et al. 2013;Wolford et al. 2013).But important questions are raised about who benefits and who loses out, and whether such large-scale projects do indeed deliver poverty-reducing development, as is often claimed.2 'High modernism' refers to an unfaltering belief in the power of science, technology and expertise to transform nature and generate an ordered, legible, technology-driven modernity.Characteristic of the development plans of the 1960s and 70s, the features are replicated in the designs, for example, of investment corridors and grid-like plans for infrastructure development today.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7137671490
FWCI:
Cites: 285
Cited by:
Related to: 9