Work

Global Dynamics and National Challenges: A Comparative Study of the Conditions Mediating Academic Freedom

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation investigates the conditions mediating academic freedom (AF) worldwide through an examination of political and institutional factors shaping it. Grounded in historical-institutionalist and sociological-institutionalist theoretical perspectives and informed by conceptual debates on political regimes, it addresses three questions: 1) What political and institutional factors mediate and shape the conditions for AF, 2) How do these relationships shift across time, space, and regime types? 3) How do national political and institutional transformations redraw the boundaries of AF within HE, demonstrated through a comparative case study of Turkey and Hungary? Employing a mixed-methods design, I compiled a panel dataset spanning 1902 – 2017 for 163 countries and analysed AF scores with fixed-effects regressions. I then carried out two country case studies on Turkey and Hungary to explore further depth how political and institutional dynamics unfold in HE systems undergoing political transformations. This stage included 26 interviews for Turkey and 25 for Hungary with scholars inside and outside of academia and exile. The findings from the quantitative data indicate that AF scores significantly rise as countries move away from closed autocratic regimes toward liberal democratic types. However, the relationship between political factors and AF is mediated by institutional factors, which in turn can amplify or buffer external pressures. The case studies reveal divergent playbooks behind similar-looking patterns of AF. While the regime in Turkey deployed authoritarian tools, such as emergency decrees, purges, and dismissals, the regime in Hungary followed neoliberal authoritarian pathway, such as legal and regulatory reforms, restructuring the governance of universities, and steering research. Three overarching insights emerge: 1) Political context remains a crucial factor shaping the conditions of AF, yet its impact can be mediated through historically embedded institutional cultures that can either protect against, or amplify, the political pressure, 2) AF is no longer a shared value that unites HE stakeholders against external pressures; university leadership now stands apart from, and sometimes even in opposition to, faculty and students, turning university into arenas of political and ideological clashes, and 3) AF, though historically rooted as a global norm, is both contested and continuously renegotiated over time and across spaces.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7139272474
Cites: 429
Cited by:
Related to: 10