Work

The Johannine School: A Distinctive Christianity in Asia Minor and the People around It

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The aim of this thesis is to provide a coherent and synthetic historical narrative of the so-called Johannine school. In previous Johannine scholarship, particularly since the development of historical-critical and socio-scientific methodologies, the existence of the Johannine school or community believed to be responsible for the Gospel of John has often been taken for granted without sufficient qualification. As such, Johannine scholars have offered diverse and undetermined discussions on the subject. This study employs R. G. Collingwood’s philosophy of history, specifically his concept of history as imagination, to interpret historical data related to the Johannine tradition and construct a more coherent historical narrative of the Johannine school. Chapter 1 examines the Quartodeciman Controversy that took place in the late second or third century CE. The chapter argues that Quartodecimanism developed as a liturgical tradition in Western Anatolia, likely aligned with the Johannine tradition. The thesis continues to deal with an unequivocal Quartodeciman practitioner, Polycarp of Smyrna. Chapter 2 focuses on The Martyrdom of Polycarp 13.1–2, suggesting that the pericope unintentionally reveals that Polycarp practiced the foot-washing liturgy within the Smyrnaean community, in line with Johannine ethos. Chapter 3 attempts to explain why in Polycarp’s extant writing, the Letter to the Philippians, only the anti-heterodox chapter 7.1–2 alludes to the Johannine tradition. It suggests that Polycarp’s heresiologist tendencies were influenced by John and exposed when he addresses the anti-heterodox issue. Chapters 4 and 5 focus on the origins of the Gospel of John. Chapter 4 interprets Irenaeus, Ignatius, and 1 John, arguing that these texts reflect an early second-century context in Asia Minor, where heterodox groups, particularly Jewish and docetic, posed a threat to Christianity. Chapter 5 explores whether the Gospel addresses these polemical issues, arguing that its soteriology has anti-gnostic tendencies, its Incarnation theology is anti-docetic, and its supersessionist stance is anti-Jewish. In conclusion, the thesis posits that the Johannine school existed as a prominent Christian community in Western Anatolia.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7139457746
Cites: 221
Cited by:
Related to: 10