Year: 2006
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The world o f informal care has become a fruitful ground for investigation particularly in relation to establishing the contextual variables o f the population o f carers and the recipients o f care.Research has highlighted that significantly more women than men are engaged in the informal delivery o f physical and personal care.A common assertion is that caring is seen predominantly as women's work and that much o f the decision making in community care is based upon such assumptions.Many empirical studies in the field o f informal care rely on traditional approaches, which confine the focus o f study to uncovering such assumptions and in so doing adopt a realistic perspective on responses.However, such studies prove problematic in that they treat language as a transparent and neutral medium for transmitting information and fail to acknowledge that responses are situationally specific, variable and deployed for particular purposes.Instead this thesis investigates the range o f discourses that formal service providers use when talking about informal caregivers.It demonstrates how these discourses attribute a range o f characteristics to informal care, which serves to pathologise it as a gendered activity.Six social care managers and six district nurses were interviewed to discuss the nature o f informal care and the method o f discursive psychology was used, which draws on the tradition o f conversation analysis as well as Bakhtinian and Foucauldian ideas.Instead o f viewing language as a transparent medium, this study sees the interplay between language and social processes and demonstrates how it both reflects and shapes informal care.This study reveals the range o f cultural, historical and professional resources drawn upon to characterise and therefore constitute informal caregiving.It demonstrates how the informants produce versions o f informal care, which draws heavily on a prior carer identity.The research reveals among other things how informal care by women is constructed as normative and informal care delivered by men as potentially deviant.The research offers a fresh insight into the social construction o f gender within social institutions and makes an important contribution to the existing corpus in gender studies.In addition the findings have important implications for policy and practice in informal care and significant issues have relevance to social work, nurse education and continuing professional development.Contents i Chapter Four Female Identity 4.0 Chapter introduction 8 8 4.1 Conventional perspectives on gender 89 4.2 Women's instinct and intuition 93 4.3 from a range o f commonsense ideologies, which preclude men from informal care.The conversational practices are analysed as a means o f investigating the variability and contradiction in accounts.Chapter six looks at how success in informal care is judged according to the occupational remits o f the two sample groups.The district nursing informants drew strong comparisons between "good" informal care and clinical nursing proficiency, while the repertoire o f the social care managers identified informal care as case management.Chapter seven focuses on how assessment is constructed as an impartial and scientific event, which is separate from the assessor and the potential implications that this has for informal caregivers.Chapter eight brings the thesis to a close and sets out the conclusions o f the research study and the potential implications for education and policy as well as for further application o f the research methodology presented.1.1 Historical perspectives on community care.Major changes in the provision o f modem health care have taken place over the last decade and this has fuelled considerable research and academic commentary.As the focus o f this thesis in some way centres on the consequences o f the changing ideology o f health care, historical issues are therefore explored in order to better understand the background to this change.Since the 1980s policy makers have become increasingly aware o f a number o f factors, which carry with them the potential for impact on the provision o f health care.As mentioned earlier, this concern has in the main, been global.Twigg et al (1990) pinpoint the economic imperative to reduce health care costs as countries and particularly the UK are faced with a changing demographic profile, which predicts higher expenditure in caring for an older population.In addition technological advances in medical and surgical techniques further contribute to the escalating cost and ultimately the increasing expectation o f society regarding the availability o f treatments and the quality o f care.This policy shift in the UK is a far cry from the newly established system o f the National Health Service with its emphasis on, as Allsop (1984) points out, the provision o f health services available without charge on the determination o f need by professional service providers.From its inception, professionals in the NHS were given carte blanche to make clinical decisions within fairly elastic financial limits, shaping and directing services as they went.As it was widely felt that the ill health o f the population could be "conquered" and that ultimately the cost for health care would fall, the government attributed for the inception o f the NHS was prepared to fund consumption through the taxation system.Chesters, L. (1994) "Women's talk: Food, weight and body image", in Wilkinson, S. (ed.) Doing it by degrees: feminist undergraduate dissertations (special feature) F em in ism a n d P s y c h o lo g y 4(3), 449-57 Chinn, P.L and Jacobs, M.K. (1987) T h eory a n d N u rsin g.A S y ste m a tic A p p ro a c h , Mosby: St. Louis
Author: Robson, Jane
Institution: Abertay University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7140247784
