Work

The Illusion of Openness: Ideological Convergence and the Limits of Critique in the Social Sciences

Year: 2026

Type: article

Abstract: The social sciences were often positioned as disciplines committed to openness, reflexivity, and critical inquiry. However, in many academic contexts, tension persisted between these claims and patterned ways of thinking. This study examined how ideological conformity emerged within social science discourse and shaped the practice of critique. Using qualitative interpretive analysis of theoretical literature, selected scholarly works, and institutional discourses, the study identified recurring commitments to power, inequality, and emancipation that had become routine disciplinary reflexes. While these frameworks had historically advanced critical scholarship, their institutionalization contributed to predictability and the narrowing of interpretive scope. Rather than viewing this as a disciplinary failure, the study interpreted ideological homogeneity as a product of historically situated academic practices and institutional norms. The paper advanced reflexive pluralism as a necessary condition for sustaining the vitality of social inquiry.

DOI: 10.17613/5y395-as286

Author: Castillo, Joven

Institutions: Polytechnic University of the Philippines, First Asia Institute of Technology and Humanities

Language: English

Topic: Contemporary Sociological Theory and Practice

Subfield: Sociology and Political Science

Field: Social Sciences

Domain: Social Sciences

Open Access status: green

OpenAlex ID: W7140329198

FWCI:

Cites:

Cited by:

Related to: