Work

Assessment on Clean Energy Transition Strategies of Oil Majors

Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The energy products of oil and gas majors have contributed significantly to global greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) and planetary warming over the past century.Decarbonizing the global economy by mid-century to avoid dangerous climate change thus cannot occur without a profound transformation of their fossil-fuel-based business models.Recently, several majors are increasingly discussing clean energy and climate change, pledging decarbonization strategies, and investing in alternative energies.Some even claim to be transforming into clean-energy companies.Given a history of obstructive climate actions and "greenwashing", there is a need to objectively evaluate current and historical decarbonization efforts and investment behavior.After introducing the background in Chapter 1, Chapter 2 describes the extant literature, in five parts: the relationship between carbon emissions and climate change, the necessity of clean transition, evaluation metrics of transition strategies and behavior, some papers related to future profitability analysis, and the related suggestions.Chapter 3 describes the methodology of the whole study.This study focuses on two American (ExxonMobil, Chevron) and two European majors (BP, Shell).Using data collected from 2009 to 2020 for the part on transition extent, the author comparatively examines the extent of decarbonization and clean energy transition activity from three perspectives: (1) keyword use in annual reports (discourse), (2) business strategies (actions), and (3) financial performance and investments (dollars).Then the author assesses the impact of participation in the Oil and Gas Climate Initiative (OGCI), using time-varying differencein-differences (DID) models.The author then breaks down the impact factors on profitability, emphasizing the carbon constraints by intermediate variable carbon emissions and substitution from clean energy.The author forecasts the future profitability by ARIMA models (Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average) for each major from 2021 to 2029.The whole profitability part uses data from 1990 to 2020.Chapter 4 concludes the findings of transition extent.The author found a strong increase in the use of keywords related to "climate", "low-carbon", and "transition", especially by BP III and Shell.Similarly, the author observed increasing tendencies toward decarbonization and clean energy strategies.But these are dominated by pledges rather than concrete actions.Conversely, the financial analysis reveals a continuing business-model dependence on fossil fuels, along with insignificant and opaque spending on clean energy.The author thus concludes that the transition to clean-energy business models is not occurring, since the magnitude of dollars and actions does not match discourse.The main reason for the contrasting behavior of American and European majors is the more aggressive emissionreduction targets and climate policies of governments in European countries.Financial factors are most predominant to explain the mismatch of pledges and actions by majors.Their green discourse and pledges could provide them with the benefits of alleviating pressure from society and prolonging their fossil-fuel business.Chapter 5 shows that the transition action of participation in OGCI is effective in reducing scope 1 emissions rather than the whole-scope carbon emissions.The time-varying model indicates that participation in OGCI has a positive relation with carbon emission.The reason for the insufficient effort of OGCI is that this companies-organized association does not require members to curb fossil-fuel production and exploration, because reducing fossil fuels would hurt the interests of board members in each energy company.Hence, mere participation in OGCI is insufficient to achieve climate targets, because of the organization's characteristics.Chapter 6 addresses the results for profitability.The profits of majors are based on fossil fuels.The fossil-fuels market offers a stage for majors to continue their conventional industry, especially with oil prices rebounding.Furthermore, carbon constraints would significantly decrease profitability for all majors, especially for the earnings-per-share (EPS) indicator.This indicates the improving awareness of investors and urgent public pleading for carbon reduction.This external pressure, combined with a range of carbon pricing policies, would accelerate and spur the clean-energy transition of energy majors.The emerging cleanenergy development would also catalyze energy majors to shift their business-as-usual (BAU) strategies to low-carbon ones.However, from the analysis of the interactive effects of clean energy, it should be admitted that renewable energies cannot currently pose a sturdy threat to fossil fuels, due to the scale IV of deployment and relatively immature technology.Although it would put majors in a dilemma-adhere to the declining fossil-fuel industry, or engage the new market without guaranteed returns-the irrevocable future shrinkage of profitability predicted by ARIMA models would hasten them to decide to become involved in the energy transition as soon as possible.Analysis in this section enhances the understanding that European majors' related poorer financial performance in the traditional fossil-fuel market would also be a key factor in forcing them to shift their competition battlefield to the clean energy market.The conclusion summarizes the overall findings of this study.Some suggestions are advanced to accelerate the energy transition through three perspectives: policymakers, industry organizations, and the companies themselves.Phasing out oil and gas-a vital step in decarbonizing economies to keep the global average temperature rise below 1.5℃ compared with pre-industrial levels-will rely on national governments initiating this process, in tandem with other industry associations and the efforts and ambitions of every incumbent energy company.
Author: 李, 玫
Institution: Tohoku University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7146077811
Cites: 63
Cited by:
Related to: 10