Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Many countries contract out social services to nongovernment providers. Governments use a range of policy mixes to delegate responsibility for services to other organisations. Do differences in the policy mixes of delegation affect people’s experiences of services at the street level? Existing studies have assumed that nongovernment services are sufficiently similar to those delivered directly by governments. They assume delegated services create consistent experiences that align with the policy goals services are to fulfil. This dissertation analyses the relationship between how delegation is implemented and people’s experiences of delegated services to show that this assumption is misleading. Examining employment services in Toronto, New York, and Amsterdam, I find that the policy mixes used to implement delegation affect people’s experiences of services delivered by nonprofits. I use the concept of nonprofit independence, the degree to which nonprofits can make unburdened choices about programme design and delivery, to show how policy mixes shape services at the street level. In all three cities, legislation contains both workfare and social investment-related policy goals. Workfare-based policies place requirements on welfare recipients to prepare for and accept any work, while social investment policies try to alter the skills of people receiving welfare to increase their chances of finding higher quality work. The municipalities of New York and Amsterdam focus more on social investment when choosing policy instruments and settings, while Toronto focuses more on workfare. However, the combination of settings and calibrations in each case shape nonprofit services differently. In Toronto and Amsterdam, the settings and calibrations of the contracting process, service requirements, payment structures, and monitoring requirements that nonprofits must follow limit nonprofit independence. As a result, employment services more consistently align with the prioritised policy aim. In New York, these settings are less restrictive and provide nonprofits with more independence to design and deliver services in line with their missions. Nonprofits can also opt out of particular government funding arrangements in New York, due to the availability of many different government and philanthropic funding streams. Nonprofit independence affects people’s experiences of services at the street level. Understanding the street level of welfare states provides a clearer understanding of how policies work in practice and provide insights into political conflict and change. The settings and calibrations of delegation alter the ideas that inform nonprofit service design, along with the incentives and working environments that street-level workers operate in. When nonprofits have more independence from government, in a shared authority model, people tend to have a wider range of experiences, as in New York. When nonprofits have less independence, under a government authority model, government policy instruments provide governments with more authority over service design and incentives that shape nonprofit behaviour, as in Toronto and Amsterdam. As a result, people have more consistent experiences. This research provides several main contributions to political science. First, it shows that street-level workers in nonprofits cannot be assumed to operate in the same way as street level bureaucrats. Instead, the organisation of delegation affects how street level workers deliver services. Second, it indicates that policy design literature ought to focus on the dynamics of policy mixes for understanding implementation and effectiveness. Third, it shows that policymakers have a choice between prioritising consistent services and allowing for more variation in services when implementing delegation. In the conclusion I reflect on the implications of this research for our understanding of the welfare state and suggest that delegation does not necessarily weaken the welfare state, it depends on how delegation is implemented.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Jansen, Alix Julia
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Public Administration
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: University of Toronto
OpenAlex ID: W7148179289
