Work

Feather Pigmentation and Abrasion: Test of a Hypothesis

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: Explanation in ecology and evolutionary biology frequently is characterized by the discernment of pattern in the natural history of organisms, followed by the inference of cause to factors thought to be sufficiently important to have given rise to the pattern.Unfortunately, the process may end at this point because of difficulties in getting real organisms to adjust their behavior, size, shape, or color in such a manner as to yield control and experimental conditions and, hence, to lead to a test of the hypothesis.Laboratory experiments may lend support or raise doubts about the hypothesis, but the verification of the importance of the hypothesized factors in natural populations frequently rests on the observation of the results of natural experiments.Recently, Burtt (1979) examined the relationship between feather coloration and wear due to abrasion.Earlier authors had mentioned anecdotal and qualitative observations about color and feather wear, for instance in the primaries of gulls (Averill 1923); Burtt, however, undertook a careful laboratory study of the abrasive effects of particles of silicon on the tail feathers of wood warblers.Based on the differential effects of this abrasion on feathers with and without melanin, along with the observed pattern of occurrence of melanic feathers among species of wood warblers, he concluded that the resistance to abrasion conferred on feathers by melanin was of sufficient importance that it should be considered an ecological function of the coloration.Nevertheless, the critical test of this hypothesis requires the observation of whether unpigmented feathers on a member of a natural population suffer significant wear due to the levels of abrasion normally encountered by a wild bird.Otherwise, one might conclude that Burtt's laboratory results were due to an unrealistically high particle flux.Recently, we happened upon a natural experiment that may help to elucidate this matter.We collected a partial albino adult male Yellow-rumped Warbler (Dendroica coronata auduboni) in the Cascade Mountains of Washington on 10 July 1977 (Bell Museum Nat.Hist.No. 31921).The albinism was limited to the outer five primaries of the bird's left wing.Thus, primary feathers with and without melanin, on the right and left wings, were exposed, since the previous molt, to the same natural
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7153678431
FWCI: 0.206
Cites:
Cited by: 13
Related to: 10