Sovereignty Without Territory: Contested Statehood, International Recognition, and Diplomatic Strategy in Contemporary Africa — South Sudan, Somaliland, and Western Sahara Compared
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The question of why some contested territorial units achieve full United Nations membership while others remain in permanent diplomatic limbo — despite comparable or superior empirical statehood credentials — is among the most consequential and theoretically under-resolved puzzles in contemporary international relations. This article develops a structured focused comparison of three African cases — South Sudan, Somaliland, and Western Sahara — across four analytical variables: empirical statehood indicators, patron-state alignment, regional organisation posture, and domestic governance legitimacy. Drawing on post-Westphalian sovereignty theory, constructivist norm emergence literature, and political settlements analysis, the article advances a dynamic recognition theory that treats international recognition not as a juridical determination triggered by legal criteria but as a strategic political process shaped by asymmetric power interactions, normative entrepreneurship, and elite bargaining at multiple governance levels. The comparative analysis reveals that patron-state alignment is the single most decisive variable in determining recognition outcomes, outweighing both empirical statehood performance and governance quality. Somaliland's paradox — strong governance, zero formal recognition — exposes the limits of liberal institutionalist assumptions embedded in standard democratisation-based recognition arguments. Western Sahara's trajectory demonstrates the self-reinforcing trap of deferred referenda: legal frameworks designed to resolve status questions instead institutionalise ambiguity. The article concludes with a typology of five diplomatic recognition strategies available to contested entities and draws implications for conflict resolution architecture in the Ho
Author: (PhD), Prof. Abraham Kuol Nyuon
Institution: University of Juba
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7154419661
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: