Work

Reference as a Cluster Concept: A Reply to Coelho Mollo and Millière

Type: article
Abstract: Coelho Mollo and Millière pose the Vector Grounding Problem: how the internal states of large language models could acquire extra-linguistic reference. They answer it with a two-condition teleosemantic account requiring causal-informational coupling to the world and a selection history that gives states the function of carrying that information. This reply accepts those teleosemantic foundations but argues that what the grounding debate calls “referential grounding” is itself a cluster concept. It bundles at least four distinct relations: teleosemantic selection, causal-informational coupling, communicative calibration, and inferential-role structure. Drawing on homeostatic property cluster theory, I replace the binary grounded/ungrounded verdict with a groundedness profile that records where a system sits on each strand. The payoff is explanatory and predictive: the profile decomposes the broader bundle often circulating under the name “grounding” into stabilizers that predict robustness, corrigibility, and characteristic failure under correction, prompt pressure, and domain shift in ways a binary verdict can't.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7154657499
Cites: 28
Cited by:
Related to: 10